Direction of Maximum Change for Function f(x, y) = x^2y^3 + xy at Point (-1, 2)

[Jennifer1990]

Homework Statement

Let f(x, y) = x^2y^3 + xy.
Is there a direction at (-1; 2) in which the rate of change of f is equal to 18?
Justify your answer.

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution

plugging this into the directional derivative formula, i get
18 = -v1 + 13v2, where v1 and v2 are the components of the vector in whose direction the rate of change is 18.
But i do not know where to go from here...

 

[danago]

What do you know about the magnitude of the gradient vector at a point?

 

[HallsofIvy]

I don't see that the "magnitude of the gradient vector" has anything to do with this problem. I do not, however, see how Jennifer1990 got that result. The gradient of f(x,y)= x^2y^3+ xy is \nabla f(x,y)= (2xy^3+y)\vec{i}+ (3x^2y^2+ x)\vec{j} and so \nabla f(-1, 2)= (2(-1)(2)^3+ 2)\vec{i}+ (3(-1)^2(2)^+ (-1))\vec{j}= -14\vec{i}+ 5\vec{j}. So the directional derivative, in the directon of vector v_1\vec{i}+ v_2\vec{j}[/tex] is <formula class="mathJaxEqu" data-display="false">-14v_1+ 5v_2= 18</formula>. Now remember that you do not want <formula class="mathJaxEqu" data-display="false">v_1</formula> and <formula class="mathJaxEqu" data-display="false">v_2</formula> themselves, you just want the direction, the ratio between them. Another way to do this is to remember that a unit vector, in the direction at angle <formula class="mathJaxEqu" data-display="false">\theta</formula> to the x-axis, is given by <formula class="mathJaxEqu" data-display="false">cos(\theta)\vec{i}+ sin(\theta)\vec{j}</formula>. Solve <formula class="mathJaxEqu" data-display="false">-14 cos(\theta)+ 5 sin(\theta)= 18</formula> for <formula class="mathJaxEqu" data-display="false">\theta</formula>.

 

[danago]

Isn't the direction of the gradient vector the one in which the function changes most rapidly, where its magnitude is the value of this greatest rate of change? When i made my suggestion, what i was getting at was the fact that the magnitude of del f is less than 18, hence there is no direction in which the rate of change is 18. My apologies if this is not correct.

 

[chriscolose]

Danago's argument is correct, since in general \nablaw is the fastest increase of w and the magnitude of \nablaw is the maximum directional derivative in that direction. HallsofIvy's logic is correct as well but the attempt to solve for theta will come up short. Keep in mind that he did not compute the "j component = 5" correctly if you attempt to go forward with what he did.

 

[HallsofIvy]

Sorry Danago, that was just too clever for me!


Oh! The j component is 3(-1)^2(2)^2+ (-1)= 11. Thanks, chriscolose.