Discover the form of real solution set

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving the inequality |4^(3x) - 2^(4x+2)*3^(x+1) + 20*12^x*3^x| > 8*6^x(8^(x-1) + 6^x). Participants explore various approaches to simplify the inequality, including factoring and substituting variables. The consensus is that the solution set should take the form (-∞, a] ∪ [b, c] ∪ [d, +∞), but there are disagreements on the correctness of the proposed solution. Key steps involve rewriting the expressions for easier manipulation and solving the corresponding equations to find critical points. Ultimately, the discussion highlights the complexity of the problem and the need for careful analysis of the functions involved.
diredragon
Messages
321
Reaction score
15

Homework Statement


##|4^{3x}-2^{4x+2}*3^{x+1}+20*12^x*3^x| > 8*6^x(8^{x-1}+6^x)##
For some numbers ##a, b, c, d## such that ##-\infty < a <b < c <d < +\infty ## the real solution set to the given inequality is of the form ##(-\infty, a] \cup [b, c] \cup [d, +\infty)## Prove it by arriving at the given result.

Homework Equations


3. The Attempt at a Solution [/B]
##a) 2^{6x}-12*2^{4x}*3^x + 20*2^{2x}*3^{2x} < -3^x*2^{4x} - 8*3^{2x}*2^{2x}##
##a) 2^{6x}-11*2^{4x}*3^x + 28*2^{2x}*3^{2x} < 0##
##a) 2^{4x}-11*2^{2x}*3^x + 28*3^{2x} < 0##

##b) 2^{6x}-12*2^{4x}*3^x + 20*2^{2x}*3^{2x} > +3^x*2^{4x} + 8*3^{2x}*2^{2x}##
##b) 2^{6x}-15*2^{4x}*3^x + 12*2^{2x}*3^{2x} > 0##
##b) 2^{4x}-15*2^{2x}*3^x + 12*3^{2x} > 0##
I don't know where to go on from this. I need to get certain numbers ##a, b, c, d## so that they would fit the result.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
diredragon said:

Homework Statement


##|4^{3x}-2^{4x+2}*3^{x+1}+20*12^x*3^x| > 8*6^x(8^{x-1}+6^x)##
For some numbers ##a, b, c, d## such that ##-\infty < a <b < c <d < +\infty ## the real solution set to the given inequality is of the form ##(-\infty, a] \cup [b, c] \cup [d, +\infty)## Prove it by arriving at the given result.

Homework Equations


3. The Attempt at a Solution [/B]
##a) 2^{6x}-12*2^{4x}*3^x + 20*2^{2x}*3^{2x} < -3^x*2^{4x} - 8*3^{2x}*2^{2x}##
##a) 2^{6x}-11*2^{4x}*3^x + 28*2^{2x}*3^{2x} < 0##
##a) 2^{4x}-11*2^{2x}*3^x + 28*3^{2x} < 0##

##b) 2^{6x}-12*2^{4x}*3^x + 20*2^{2x}*3^{2x} > +3^x*2^{4x} + 8*3^{2x}*2^{2x}##
##b) 2^{6x}-15*2^{4x}*3^x + 12*2^{2x}*3^{2x} > 0##
##b) 2^{4x}-15*2^{2x}*3^x + 12*3^{2x} > 0##
I don't know where to go on from this. I need to get certain numbers ##a, b, c, d## so that they would fit the result.

You can plot both sides of the inequality, and if you do that you will see that the proposed answer is incorrect: the solution set is not of the form specified.
 
Ray Vickson said:
You can plot both sides of the inequality, and if you do that you will see that the proposed answer is incorrect: the solution set is not of the form specified.
I'm not sure about this. It certanly must be the answer as the book from which the problem was takrn suggests. It also appeared in the math test I've taken last week and the professor is going to explain the solution next week. I tried to solve it beforehand but i arrive at this last line. I can't figure out what to do next, or if I've made a mistake in betweed.
 
diredragon said:
I'm not sure about this. It certanly must be the answer as the book from which the problem was takrn suggests. It also appeared in the math test I've taken last week and the professor is going to explain the solution next week. I tried to solve it beforehand but i arrive at this last line. I can't figure out what to do next, or if I've made a mistake in betweed.

My apologies: plotting is tricky, because of the vast order-of-magnitude changes in both sides over reasonable ranges of x. However, by simplifying and dividing by a common (always positive) factor, we have more easily-plotted functions, and your claimed result does turn out to be true.
 
Last edited:
Notice that ##\ 3^{2x}=(3^x)^2\ ## and ##\ 2^{4x}=(2^{2x})^2\ ## .
 
  • Like
Likes diredragon
The simplest way to solve an ineqVuality is often to solve the corresponding equation. Since both sides are continuous functions of x and y, the curve where 'A= B' separates 'A< B' from 'A> B'. That means you want to solve 2^{4x}-11*2^{2x}*3^x + 28*3^{2x}= 0. To do that let u= 2^x and y= 3^x. As SammyS pointed out, 2^{4x}= (2^x)^2= u^2 and 3^{2x}= (3^x)^2= y^2 so the equation becomes x^2- 11xy+ 28y^2= 0. You should find that quadratic easy to factor.
 
  • Like
Likes diredragon
HallsofIvy said:
The simplest way to solve an ineqVuality is often to solve the corresponding equation. Since both sides are continuous functions of x and y, the curve where 'A= B' separates 'A< B' from 'A> B'. That means you want to solve 2^{4x}-11*2^{2x}*3^x + 28*3^{2x}= 0. To do that let u= 2^x and y= 3^x. As SammyS pointed out, 2^{4x}= (2^x)^2= u^2 and 3^{2x}= (3^x)^2= y^2 so the equation becomes x^2- 11xy+ 28y^2= 0. You should find that quadratic easy to factor.
You mean ##u=2^{2x}## and then the equation stands as ##u^2 - 11uy + 28y^2=0##.
##(u - \frac{11y}{2})^2 - \frac{9y^2}{4} = 0##
##(u - \frac{11y}{2})^2 = \frac{9y^2}{4}##
##u - \frac{11y}{2} = \frac{3y}{2}##
Is this right?
 
diredragon said:
You mean ##u=2^{2x}## and then the equation stands as ##u^2 - 11uy + 28y^2=0##.
##(u - \frac{11y}{2})^2 - \frac{9y^2}{4} = 0##
##(u - \frac{11y}{2})^2 = \frac{9y^2}{4}##
##u - \frac{11y}{2} = \frac{3y}{2}##
Is this right?

I think it is more complicated than that. If ##f(x) = 4^{3x}-2^{4x+2}\,3^{x+1}+20 \,12^x \,3^x## and ##g(x) = 8\,6^x(8^{x-1}+6^x)## you need to look at the two different problems ##f(x) > 0\: \& \:f(x) > g(x)## and ##f(x) < 0\: \& \: -f(x) > g(x)##.
 
Ray Vickson said:
I think it is more complicated than that. If ##f(x) = 4^{3x}-2^{4x+2}\,3^{x+1}+20 \,12^x \,3^x## and ##g(x) = 8\,6^x(8^{x-1}+6^x)## you need to look at the two different problems ##f(x) > 0\: \& \:f(x) > g(x)## and ##f(x) < 0\: \& \: -f(x) > g(x)##.
The expression i got in post #7 is taken as the first part of the problem, mainly ##f(x) < g(x)## , i then needed to set ##f(x) = g(x)## but i arrive at what i posted in #7. Dont know how to continue...
 
  • #10
diredragon said:
You mean ##u=2^{2x}## and then the equation stands as ##u^2 - 11uy + 28y^2=0##.
##(u - \frac{11y}{2})^2 - \frac{9y^2}{4} = 0##
##(u - \frac{11y}{2})^2 = \frac{9y^2}{4}##
##u - \frac{11y}{2} = \frac{3y}{2}##
Is this right?
That can be solved for u. However there is one more solution, which you have dropped somehow.

... but ... Getting those two solutions is not that complicated.

As Halls said, factor the left hand side of
##u^2 - 11uy + 28y^2=0##​

##(u-4y)(u+7y)=0##
 
Last edited:
  • #11
SammyS said:
That can be solved for u. However there is one more solution, which you have dropped somehow.

... but ... Getting those two solutions is not that complicated.

As Halls said, factor the left hand side of
##u^2 - 11uy + 28y^2=0##​

##(u-4y)(u+7y)=0##
So, ##(u-4y)(u+7y)=0##
##u-4y=0## and ##u+7y=0##
##2^{2x-2} = 3^x## and ##2^{2x} = -7*3^{x}##
How to solve this?
 
  • #12
diredragon said:
So, ##(u-4y)(u+7y)=0##
##u-4y=0## and ##u+7y=0##
##2^{2x-2} = 3^x## and ##2^{2x} = -7*3^{x}##
How to solve this?
In both equations, you need to get the same base on each side of the equation. For example, ##2 = e^{\ln 2}##. Use this idea and the properties of exponents to solve each equation.
 
  • #13
diredragon said:
So, ##(u-4y)(u+7y)=0##
##u-4y=0## and ##u+7y=0##
##2^{2x-2} = 3^x## and ##2^{2x} = -7*3^{x}##
How to solve this?

Your problem has the form ##|L(x)| > R(x)##, where
L(x) = 4^{3x}-2^{4x+2}*3^{x+1}+20*12^x*3^x = 64^x-12\,48^x+20\,36^x
and
R(x) = 8*6^x(8^{x-1}+6^x) = 48^x+8 \, 36^x
Write ##L(x) = 36^x \, f(x)## and ##R(x) = 36^x \, g(x)##, where
f(x) = 20 - 12\,(48/36)^x + (64/36)^x = 20 - 12\,(4/3)^x + (16/9)^x
and
g(x) = 8+(48/36)^x = 8 + (4/3)^x
Since ##36^x > 0## always, the inequalities ##|L(x)| > R(x)## and ##|f(x)| > g(x)## are equivalent. Setting ##(4/3)^x = y## we have ##f(x) = 20 - 12 y + y^2## and ##g(x) = 8+y##, so the problem becomes ##|20 - 12 y + y^2| > y+8##.
 
  • #14
diredragon said:
So, ##(u-4y)(u+7y)=0##
##u-4y=0## and ##u+7y=0##
##2^{2x-2} = 3^x## and ##2^{2x} = -7*3^{x}##
How to solve this?
First of all, somebody made a mistake in factoring ##\ u^2 - 11uy + 28y^2\,.\ ## o:)

Of course that is: ##\ (u-4y)(u-7y)\ ##

I think you're much better off to think of ##\ 2^{2x}\ ## as ##\ 4^{x}\ ##.

Solve for u/y or y/u

Notice that ##\displaystyle\ \frac u y = \left(\frac 4 3\right)^x \ ##

This all is handy if you are following the advice from Halls.
 
Back
Top