Do you have an edition of Hamlet at hand?

  • Thread starter Thread starter honestrosewater
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    hand
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a specific passage from Shakespeare's "Hamlet," particularly Act I, Scene I, where Horatio speaks to Marcellus after the Ghost's appearance. The original poster seeks clarification on various word choices in different editions of the text, specifically regarding the terms "these/those," "of/on," "returned/return," "compart/compact," and "design/design'd." They express a desire for a comprehensive understanding of the differences across editions, as they aim to make an informed decision about which version to use. Participants share their own editions, noting discrepancies, and highlight resources like Project Gutenberg for accessing multiple versions. The conversation emphasizes the challenges of navigating various texts and annotations while seeking clarity on Shakespeare's language.
honestrosewater
Gold Member
Messages
2,133
Reaction score
6
Long story short: I had some. I had to donate them. I don't want to buy them again if I don't need them. I only need a few lines right now. It's perfectly kosher, IMHO. So...

If anyone has a version other than the First Folio or Second Quarto, I'll grant you one wish if you tell me what it says within the question marks:

Did forfeit (with his life) all ?these/those? his lands
Which he stood seized ?of/on?, to the conqueror.
Against the which a moiety competent
Was gagEd by our King, which had ?returned/return?
To the inheritance of Fortinbras,
Had he been vanquisher; as by the same ?compart/compact/Cov’nant?
And carriage of the article ?design/designed?
To locate it: This is Horatio speaking to Marcellus in Act I, Scene I, after the Ghost has entered and exited for the first time. It's a rather long speech, which begins with "That can I. At least the whisper goes so...", and you may find it around line #105. It'll be on the first page or two, so you can just scan for the first lengthy speech.

If you have an annotated edition and there are notes about this part, I would love it if you could give me the details regarding the options in question. This would be extremely helpful, because I want to make an informed decision.

Thanks so much. :smile:
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
My copy gives:

Did forfeit (with his life) all those his lands
Which he stood seized of to the conqueror.
Against the which a moiety competent
Was gagEd by our King, which had returned
To the inheritance of Fortinbras,
Had he been vanquisher; as by the same cov’nant

My edition: Shakespeare made easy :blushing:
 
http://www.shakespearefellowship.org/virtualclassroom/Law/legalhamlet/act1-1.htm

Google is your friend. :smile:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thanks, Doc Al. I just realized that I had forgotten a line, but don't worry about it, I bet that your says "design'd" anyway. :smile: (You have one wish.)
 
TheStatutoryApe said:
http://www.shakespearefellowship.org/virtualclassroom/Law/legalhamlet/act1-1.htm

Google is your friend. :smile:
O, the shame. I thought I was the Google Queen. :redface: You rock, mister Ape! :biggrin:
Okay, I'll use this site later, so it's a big help. It addresses the comart issue, but not the others. I kind of wanted comart to be a typo of compart, which meant to divide into parts. This fits with carriage, the administration of those parts:
as by the same compart and carriage of the article design(ed),
as by the same division and admistration (of lands) of the article design(ed)​
which is what the compact did. It has the right rhythm too. Bah, I want all the choices not mentioned so far.

I still would like a variety of sources on this one. It is giving me problems.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
honestrosewater said:
I bet that your says "design'd" anyway.
Yep, the next line is:
And carriage of the article designed,​
 
Doc Al said:
Yep, the next line is:
And carriage of the article designed,​
And design'd is in neither F1 nor Q2! It's design in both! They just changed it for some reason. :rolleyes:
 
dduardo said:
Project Gutenberg is your friend:

http://www.gutenberg.org/etext/1524

They have a huge collection of ebooks in all types of formats.
Thanks, I love PG but wasn't familiar with the Collins Edition. This is crazy - between the editions, transcriptions of the editions, and facsimiles, I'm going to have over a dozen tabs open at once. They get hard to keep track of after a while.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top