Doubt about solution -- Two masses connected by a rod moving on a surface

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the mechanics of two masses connected by a rod and the nature of forces acting on them. Participants express confusion about how the system operates, particularly questioning the idea that all forces are pulling forces and how mass 1 can move to the right while being connected to the rod. Clarifications are made regarding the forces exerted by the masses on the rod, with emphasis on the direction of these forces. The role of static friction is also debated, with some skepticism about its ability to facilitate movement. Ultimately, the consensus is that the connection implies some form of secure attachment between the masses and the rod.
String theory guy
Messages
26
Reaction score
4
Homework Statement
The statement is below.
Relevant Equations
Newton's Second Law
The doubt is about this question.
1671078556063.png

Which the answer is
1671078745584.png

They say that all the forces are pulling forces? How is this the case?

How would this setup even work? I don't think block 2 could pull the rod.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
String theory guy said:
They say that all the forces are pulling forces? How is this the case?
Can you find one that isn't?
 
  • Love
Likes String theory guy
Yes I can @haruspex :
F1, rod
F2, rod
 
String theory guy said:
Yes I can @haruspex :
F1, rod
F2, rod
F1,rod is the force m1 exerts on the rod. That force pulls the rod to the left.
 
  • Love
Likes String theory guy
haruspex said:
F1,rod is the force m1 exerts on the rod. That force pulls the rod to the left.
I thought it was the opposite way round. How did you derive that @haruspex ?
 
String theory guy said:
I thought it was the opposite way round. How did you derive that @haruspex ?
Do you mean, how do I know that F1,rod is the force m1 exerts on the rod, not the force the rod exerts on m1? Because clearly everything does move to the right, and the only way m1 is going to move to the right is if the force the rod exerts on m1 is to the right. So that must be Frod,1.
But the question ought to have made the notation clear.
 
  • Love
Likes String theory guy
haruspex said:
Do you mean, how do I know that F1,rod is the force m1 exerts on the rod, not the force the rod exerts on m1? Because clearly everything does move to the right, and the only way m1 is going to move to the right is if the force the rod exerts on m1 is to the right. So that must be Frod,1.
But the question ought to have made the notation clear.
Yea that is my doubt I think @haruspex - how dose everything in the system move to the right? Is there some glue or something between the block and masses? That is the only way I can see mass 1 moving to the right being in contact with the rod that is moving to the right.

I don't know, but the force of static friction should not be that great allowing the rod to pull mass 1.
 
String theory guy said:
Is there some glue or something between the block and masses?
It says they're connected, so I would take that as meaning they are somehow secured together.
 
  • Love
Likes String theory guy
Back
Top