Electric Potential Difference -- Conceptual Question

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the electric potential difference between two concentric shells: an inner shell with radius a and charge Q, and an outer shell with radius b and charge -4Q. The user is confused about the correct expression for the potential difference, questioning why it is V1 - V2 rather than V2 - V1. Clarification is sought regarding the measurement method and the relationship between the electric field direction and potential difference. The shells are made of insulating material with uniform charge distribution, and the potential is defined as zero at an infinite distance. The conversation emphasizes the importance of accurately describing the problem setup to resolve the confusion.
anon1234
Messages
4
Reaction score
2
Homework Statement
Potential difference (ΔV)measured by the student between the inner solid sphere and outer shell after putting a charge - 4Q is :
Relevant Equations
v = kq/r
I am able to get V1 = kq/a - 4kq/b
and V2 = kq/b + -4kq/b

For some reason the solution says it is V1-V2 as opposed to V2-V1.

Maybe has something to do with positive shell in the center and negative outer shell? I know the electric field goes from positive to negative, but I don't know how they relate.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Please post a figure of the problem or describe it the best way you can. Your description of the problem is incomplete. Do we have a solid sphere of radius a and charge Q, surrounded by a shell of radius b and charge -4Q? Or do we have two shells? I really can't understand.
 
Last edited:
Delta2 said:
Please post a figure of the problem or describe it the best way you can. Your description of the problem is incomplete. Do we have a solid sphere of radius a and charge Q, surrounded by a shell of radius b and charge -4Q? Or do we have two shells? I really can't understand.
It is 2 concentric shells. The first shell has radius a (charge Q), and the second shell has radius b (with charge -4Q).
 
How is the student measuring it? That might matter.
 
hutchphd said:
How is the student measuring it? That might matter.
I hope this is ample info.

Both shells are made of insulating material, and the charges are distributed uniformly over its surface. Take the electric potential to be zero at an infinite distance from both shells. What is the magnitude of the potential difference between the surfaces
of the two shells?
 
anon1234 said:
What is the magnitude
This phrase implies a positive number...(?)
 
  • Like
Likes Delta2
hutchphd said:
This phrase implies a positive number...(?)
lol. ty!
 
  • Like
Likes Delta2 and hutchphd
Back
Top