Electron-Proton Fusion?

  • Thread starter HarryWertM
  • Start date
99
0

Main Question or Discussion Point

1a. Is possible for an electron and a proton to fuse?

1b. If yes, do you get a neutron?

2. What PREVENTS protons and electrons fusing together in plasma [like in tokamak]?

-Harry Wertmuller
 

Answers and Replies

malawi_glenn
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
4,782
22
1.a Yes

1.b Yes, we get a neutron and a neutrino. This is called electron capture

2. I'll leave that til an expert in plasma physics (since I am not one of those) :-)
 
Astronuc
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
18,542
1,684
A 'free' neutron is unstable with respect to beta decay, i.e. a neutron by itself will decay into a proton, beta and anti-neutrino, so the reverse action is unlikely. I suspect that electron capture may occur very rarely.

EC does happen in certain proton-rich (neutron deficient) radionuclides, and typically it is a K-electron which is absorbed. In plasmas, the ions and electrons have kinetic energies much, much greater than the binding energy of electrons (in the light elements). At lower energies, electrons recombine with ions to form neutral atoms, which then leak out of plasmas.

Protons (or more generally ions) and electrons interact in plasma, mostly by scattering or producing bremsstrahlung radiation, the latter of which results in energy loss from the plasma.

Fusion plasmas are likely to be D+D or D+T. D+3He would be preferable since it's an aneutronic reaction, but it requires higher temperatures (with concommitant pressure for a given particle density) and 3He is extremely rare (and thus very expensive). He-3 can be obtained from the beta decay of T (H-3).

Proton-proton fusion has a very low cross-section, and is the basis of one fusion process in stars - PP fusion or PP-chain.
http://csep10.phys.utk.edu/astr162/lect/energy/ppchain.html

Otherwise, there are more exotic reaction like p + 11B -> 3 4He, but that requires significantly higher temperature than D+D or D+T.

p + p -> d + e+ + 1.4 MeV, but
p + d -> 3He + gamma + 5.5 MeV
 
979
1
1a. Is possible for an electron and a proton to fuse?

1b. If yes, do you get a neutron?

2. What PREVENTS protons and electrons fusing together in plasma [like in tokamak]?

-Harry Wertmuller
1a. Yes

1b. Yes, and also a neutrino.

2. The interaction cross-section is *very* small --- the reaction is mediated by the weak force, which is not called the weak force for nothing.
 
99
0
Hmmm.. Astronuc wrote: "EC does happen in certain ... neutron deficient radionuclides and typically it is a K electron..."

Q: Can you describe or cite experiment where EC happens or happened?

Q: What is K electron? Lowest energy orbit in Hydrogen? So then does probability of EC INCREASE if they make one of those "Bose-Einstein" condensates using deuterium-free hydrogen?
 
Last edited:
2,400
6
Q: Can you describe or cite experiment where EC happens or happened?
Are you questioning the possibility that it happens ?
You can search Google for many peer-reviewed publications.
Q: What is K electron? Lowest energy orbit in Hydrogen? So then does probability of EC INCREASE if they make one of those "Bose-Einstein" condensates using deuterium-free hydrogen?
A K-electron is indeed one in the lowest shell. But hydrogen is irrelevant for neutron capture. Here you want larger nuclei isotopes with too many protons, but such that beta+ decay (positron emission) is forbidden.

Electron capture
 
Astronuc
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
18,542
1,684
Hmmm.. Astronuc wrote: "EC does happen in certain ... neutron deficient radionuclides and typically it is a K electron..."

Q: Can you describe or cite experiment where EC happens or happened?

Q: What is K electron? Lowest energy orbit in Hydrogen? So then does probability of EC INCREASE if they make one of those "Bose-Einstein" condensates using deuterium-free hydrogen?
http://www.nndc.bnl.gov/chart/ has a listing of all radionuclides and decay modes. Click on a location on the chart and select Zoom 1 at the top right of the chart.

The isotopes above or to the right of the black squares (stable elements) are proton-rich (neutron deficient) and preferentially decay by EC (electron capture, or K-capture), or in some cases positron emission. The further away the radionuclide is from the line of stability (black squares) the more rare it is, and usually it has a very short half-life.

Electron capture is dependent on nuclear properties, and should not be dramatically affected by the chemical form (BEC), i.e. BEC would not increase probability of EC in H, or D, or whatever.
 
99
0
Astronuc; Humanino; Thank you. Did not THINK of Googling. Did not know "ELECTRON CAPTURE" were the magic words.

Google results yield another problem -- us civilians do not have access to and/or cannot afford sources like Physical Review Letters.

Nuclides chart is really impressive. Thanks again.
 
Last edited:
2,400
6
Google results yield another problem -- us civilians do not have access to and/or cannot afford sources like Physical Review Letters.
That's true unfortunately. However, most recent articles are available for free on arXiv. In addition, if you go to a university librairy for instance, you can find those articles printed.
 

Related Threads for: Electron-Proton Fusion?

  • Last Post
Replies
7
Views
7K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
900
  • Last Post
Replies
11
Views
7K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
5K
  • Last Post
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
12
Views
4K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
5K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
25
Views
3K
Top