Expanding function with spherical harmonics

2 replies · 6K views · last reply
Integratethis
Messages
1
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


The function cos(theta)*cos(phi) in spherical coordinates cannot be expanded to a series of spherical harmonics. Explain why.

Homework Equations


As far as I can recall, the spherical harmonics are a complete set over a sphere, meaning every function which is SI over a sphere can be expanded to such a series...including this one.

The Attempt at a Solution


Tried everything I can think of - got to the point in which I need to prove that the coefficient for each Y(l,m=+-1) = 0, but couldn't find a way around it.
 
Integratethis said:
Tried everything I can think of - got to the point in which I need to prove that the coefficient for each Y(l,m=+-1) = 0, but couldn't find a way around it.
You can't prove that because it's not true. The coefficient of Y21, for instance, is not 0. I'm not sure what the problem is getting at because, as you said, the spherical harmonics are a complete set and the function is square-integrable on the sphere.