Is Human Behavior Governed by Fate or Liberty?

  • Thread starter JPC
  • Start date
In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of fate versus liberty and whether or not humans are truly in control of their actions. The speaker argues that as rational beings, fate is the more plausible explanation as everything in the universe follows physical rules. They also suggest that humans are not so different from non-living things and are essentially complex structures made up of atoms. The idea of randomness is also brought up and the speaker believes that even seemingly random things can be predicted through equations. They also mention the possibility of alien life and the complexity of defining life. Overall, the conversation touches on the deterministic nature of the universe and how it relates to the concept of free will.
  • #1
JPC
206
1
Hey is there Fate or Liberty ?

as a rational person i would say fate , because everything around us obeys to physical rules. For everything there are very very very long equations (for exact exact exact results)
and we are not so different from the non-living, we are made up of atoms. I would say we are like a complex structure made up of materials. The reactions inside us (including outside factors , example : light) make up our actions + thoughts.
We are like a series of reactions.

And there's no random with physics;
for example the random function of our calculator is not that random , neither are some of the machines in the casinos. You could make up big equations to predict their result (even throught its hard and long to do)


I think , we place non-living and living too far apart. For us we can generally say that we hope to find alien creatures with a sort of DNA. Because life is just an impression. I say the living are compex structures whose actions are determined by iner-reactions + structure and exterior factors and that have a big possibility of actions. Well hard to make a definition. But let's just stick to DNA
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
If I have understood your point correctly, you are talking about a deterministic universe. I do believe in your results becuse of cause & effect theorm, which is indirectly what you have just written. You might find different ideas on this topic interesting.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_will
 
  • #3
and other genetic material.

I would approach this question from a scientific perspective. Fate and liberty are concepts that have been debated for centuries, but in terms of scientific evidence, there is no clear answer. From a physical standpoint, everything in our universe follows certain laws and rules, and our actions and thoughts are a result of these physical interactions. This could be seen as a sense of fate, as our actions are predetermined by these physical laws.

However, as humans, we also have the ability to make choices and decisions, which could be seen as a sense of liberty. Our brains are incredibly complex and have the ability to process and analyze information, leading to our decision-making processes. This could be seen as a form of free will.

Ultimately, the question of fate or liberty may never have a definitive answer. It could be argued that both concepts coexist, as our actions are influenced by both predetermined physical laws and our own choices. As scientists, it is important to continue studying and researching these concepts, but we must also acknowledge that some questions may not have a concrete answer.
 

Related to Is Human Behavior Governed by Fate or Liberty?

What is the concept of "Fate or Liberty"?

The concept of "Fate or Liberty" refers to the age-old debate about whether our lives are predetermined by fate or if we have the freedom to make our own choices and shape our own destinies.

How does science approach the question of "Fate or Liberty"?

Science approaches the question of "Fate or Liberty" by studying the underlying mechanisms that influence our behavior and decision-making. Through experiments and observations, scientists aim to uncover how much of our actions are determined by external factors and how much is within our control.

What do scientific studies say about the role of genes in "Fate or Liberty"?

Many scientific studies have shown that genes play a significant role in influencing our behavior and personality traits, but they do not determine our fate. While our genetic makeup may make us more prone to certain behaviors, we still have the ability to make choices and change our paths.

Can our environment impact our "Fate or Liberty"?

Yes, our environment can have a significant impact on our "Fate or Liberty." Our surroundings, such as our upbringing, social influences, and life experiences, can shape our beliefs, values, and choices. However, we still have the power to overcome these external influences and make our own decisions.

Is there a definitive answer to the question of "Fate or Liberty"?

No, there is no definitive answer to the question of "Fate or Liberty." It is a complex and multifaceted topic that has been debated for centuries. While science can provide insights and evidence, the interpretation of this information ultimately depends on individual beliefs and perspectives.

Similar threads

  • General Discussion
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • General Discussion
Replies
3
Views
834
Replies
19
Views
1K
  • General Discussion
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
926
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
14
Views
7K
  • General Discussion
Replies
6
Views
886
  • Science Fiction and Fantasy Media
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
3
Views
654
Back
Top