Find acceleration between two blocks (bottom block)

11 replies · 3K views · last reply
isukatphysics69
Messages
453
Reaction score
8
Physics problem screenshot: a 1.0 kg block tied to a wall by a rope sits on a 2.0 kg block, which is pulled right by a 20 N force arrow. Question 3 asks for the tension in the rope holding the 1.0 kg block.
Screenshot of an online quiz question asking for the acceleration of the 2.0 kg block, with the answer 1.44m/s^2 entered and marked incorrect with a red cross, and a 'Marks for this submission: 0.00/1.00' message.
1. Homework Statement

Problem in pictures

Homework Equations


f=ma

The Attempt at a Solution


So the tension force is 20N, i took the frictional force on the bottom of the block as 3*9.8*.4 because the bottom of the block has a total mass of top block and bottom block = 3kg, so i have 20N - friction between top and bottom block - friction between bottom block and surface = 20N - 11.76N - 3.92N = 4.32N DIVIDED BY A TOTAL OF 3KG (TOP AND BOTTOM BLOCK) = 1.44 M/S^2.. why is this wrong?
 
Attachments
  • Physics problem screenshot: a 1.0 kg block tied to a wall by a rope sits on a 2.0 kg block, which is pulled right by a 20 N force arrow. Question 3 asks for the tension in the rope holding the 1.0 kg block.
    mar30.PNG
    15.1 KB · Views: 1,261
  • Screenshot of an online quiz question asking for the acceleration of the 2.0 kg block, with the answer 1.44m/s^2 entered and marked incorrect with a red cross, and a 'Marks for this submission: 0.00/1.00' message.
    mar302.PNG
    11.9 KB · Views: 973
haruspex said:
Why?
because the total mass is 3kg, the 2kg block has a 1kg block on top. so if i pull with 20N i have to take into account the top block an additional 1kg
 
isukatphysics69 said:
because the total mass is 3kg, the 2kg block has a 1kg block on top. so if i pull with 20N i have to take into account the top block an additional 1kg
Which system did you compute the forces on? What is the total mass of that system?
 
Orodruin said:
Which system did you compute the forces on? What is the total mass of that system?
hey i figured that problem out, do you understand ranking forces?
 
i never read the problems carefully because i am an idiot, i could have gotten a B on my calc 2 exam but i got a C because i was looking for volume rather than surface area, i didn't realize until i only had 20 minutes left for the exam and i ended up with a C
 
But this ranking forces stuff is still very confusing
 
Screenshot of a physics homework question showing a schematic of two boxes labelled A and B against a smooth, frictionless wall, with a force arrow above, followed by ranking instructions and a submitted answer line.

Vertical forces, Force on block A from hand > force on block b from block A > force gravity on block A from Earth > force gravity on block b from Earth > force friction between both blocks that are equal

Incorrect
 
Attachments
  • Screenshot of a physics homework question showing a schematic of two boxes labelled A and B against a smooth, frictionless wall, with a force arrow above, followed by ranking instructions and a submitted answer line.
    mar304.PNG
    23.8 KB · Views: 905
isukatphysics69 said:
View attachment 223106
Vertical forces, Force on block A from hand > force on block b from block A > force gravity on block A from Earth > force gravity on block b from Earth > force friction between both blocks that are equal

Incorrect
That last attempt is clearly wrong since you have FFBA > ... FFBA.
It might help if you start by writing out the usual force balance equations for each block.