Finding the step response of RL circuit

8 replies · 4K views · last reply
Vishera
Messages
72
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement



Handwritten-style solution page for Chapter 7 Problem 59 with a circuit schematic and derivation of the step response v0(t) of an RL circuit, ending with v0(t) = 6e^-4t u(t) V.


Homework Equations


The Attempt at a Solution



I understand everything except how they got i(∞). It seems like they used current division on 3A. But where are they applying current division and where did they get 3A? Also, in the last step, they magically added u(t). Where did they get that from?
 
Looks like they failed to specify that the magnitude of the step for Vs was 18 V.
 
gneill said:
Looks like they failed to specify that the magnitude of the step for Vs was 18 V.

Oh, opps. That was my mistake. It looks like the problem is slightly different in two places.

Here's the problem:

Circuit schematic for Problem 7.59 showing a voltage source vs in series with a 6 ohm resistor feeding a parallel branch of a 3 ohm resistor and a 1.5 H inductor, with vo taken across a 4 ohm resistor in series with the inductor.


But I still don't see where they got the 3A and where u(t) in the last step came from.
 
Supposing that the source voltage will be 18 V for "a long time", what current be the steady state current provided by the source?

The u(t) specifies that the solution pertains to time t > 0 since the source is stepped from 0 V to 18 V according to 18u(t) V.
 
You can write (18-v)/6 = v(1/3 + 1/4).
So 3 = v(1/6 + 1/3 + 1/4) = v(1/2 + 1/4)

So there's your 3A on the left ...

and i = v/4 = 3/(4/2 + 4/4) = 3*2/(4+2) = 1A for i(infinity).

Just how he managed to get to 3*2/(4+2) immediately I don't know.
 
gneill said:
Supposing that the source voltage will be 18 V for "a long time", what current be the steady state current provided by the source?

The u(t) specifies that the solution pertains to time t > 0 since the source is stepped from 0 V to 18 V according to 18u(t) V.

Would the below be correct?

Circuit schematic with an 18 V source and 6 Ω resistor in series to a node labelled V, which connects to a 3 Ω resistor to ground and a 4 Ω resistor in series with a 1.5 H inductor to the bottom wire, with i(∞) marked downward.


$$\frac { v-18 }{ 6 } +\frac { v-0 }{ 3 } +\frac { v-0 }{ 4 } =0\\ v=4\\ \\ i(∞)=\frac { v-0 }{ 4 } =1\quad A$$

rude man said:
You can write (18-v)/6 = v(1/3 + 1/4).
So 3 = v(1/6 + 1/3 + 1/4) = v(1/2 + 1/4)

So there's your 3A on the left ...

I can see how you manipulated that equation to get 3A on the left side but I don't understand what the right side means. On the right side, we have a sum of 3 currents: v/6, v/3, and v/4. v/3 is the current from v to ground through the 3-ohm resistor. v/4 is the current from v to ground through the 4-ohm resistor. But what is v/6? It can't be the current from v to ground through the 6-ohm resistor because a 6-ohm resistor doesn't exist between v and ground. I just don't see where the 3A current is on the circuit.
 
Vishera said:
Would the below be correct?

Circuit schematic: 18 V source with 6 Ω resistor to node V, a 3 Ω resistor from V to ground, and a 4 Ω resistor in series with a 1.5 H inductor from V to ground; current i(∞) marked downward in the right branch.


$$\frac { v-18 }{ 6 } +\frac { v-0 }{ 3 } +\frac { v-0 }{ 4 } =0\\ v=4\\ \\ i(∞)=\frac { v-0 }{ 4 } =1\quad A$$



I can see how you manipulated that equation to get 3A on the left side but I don't understand what the right side means. On the right side, we have a sum of 3 currents: v/6, v/3, and v/4. v/3 is the current from v to ground through the 3-ohm resistor. v/4 is the current from v to ground through the 4-ohm resistor. But what is v/6? It can't be the current from v to ground through the 6-ohm resistor because a 6-ohm resistor doesn't exist between v and ground. I just don't see where the 3A current is on the circuit.

You're looking for an actual 3A in the circuit where none exists. The 3A is just the result of rewriting my original equation which simply says that the current from the source to the v node = the sum of currents from the v node to ground.
 
rude man said:
the current from the source to the v node = the sum of currents from the v node to ground.

I disagree here. On the right side, you had the term v/6 which is not a current from the v node to ground because there isn't a 6-ohm resistor between the v node and ground.
 
Vishera said:
I disagree here. On the right side, you had the term v/6 which is not a current from the v node to ground because there isn't a 6-ohm resistor between the v node and ground.

"I do not agree with what you have to say, but I'll defend to the death your right to say it." :smile:
Voltaire