Force exerted from car on trailer question

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the force exerted by a car on a trailer, given the car's mass, trailer's mass, and friction coefficient. Initial calculations led to confusion regarding the net force and whether to consider kinetic friction on the car. The correct approach involves using free-body diagrams and Newton's laws to derive the force exerted on the trailer, which was found to be approximately 1024N. Clarification was provided that the question seeks the force in two significant digits, and a solution of 1000N was accepted despite the request for precision. The conversation highlights the importance of understanding the dynamics between the car and trailer to arrive at the correct answer.
Joshuava
Messages
6
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



A 1480(k)g car pulls a 300(k)g trailer. The car exerts a horizontal force of 3900(N) against the ground in order to accelerate.

What force does the car exert on the trailer? Assume an effective friction coefficient of 0.15 for the trailer.

Homework Equations


My question really is how to solve this problem correctly, but more so, correcting the mistakes I have made in my attempt in gathering a correct solution. I will just put all my work that way anyone who looks at this can easily follow my path and be able to correct my work.

The Attempt at a Solution



Normal force on car = 1480(kg) * 9.81(m/s^2) = 14518.8(N)
Friction on car = 14518.8(N) * 0.15 = 2177.82(N)

Normal force on trailer = 300(kg) * 9.81(m/s^2) = 2943(N)
Friction on trailer = 2943(N) * 0.15 = 441.45(N)

3900(N) in my problem will be working in the positive direction as the other forces are resisting movement due to friction:

F = 3900(N) - 2177.82(N) - 441.45(N) => 1280.73(N)

Now, using Newton's 2nd law of F = m * a, I have rearranged to solve for acceleration:
a = F / m

a = 1280.73(N) / [1480(kg) + 300(kg)] =>0.7195(m/s^2)

F(trailer)=m(trailer) * a(trailer) + any other additional forces acting on the trailer?

F(trailer) = 300(kg) * 0.7195(m/s^2) + 441.45(N) => 657.3(N)

660(N) is my solution.

Would anyone be kind enough to help correct my mistakes? I appreciate you taking the time to take a look!
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
It is said in the problem statement that 0.15 is for the trailer only so does that mean 3900N is a net force so kinetic friction on the car can be neglected?
 
Last edited:
This was copied directly from masteringphysics so I really can't answer that question...I just attempted to solve it as best I could, but my answer is not what it is looking for.

That would change the answer significantly.

The new F would be 3458.55(N)

acceleration would change to 1.94(m/s^2)

The new F(trailer) would be 300(kg) * 1.94(m/s^2) + 441.45 => 1024.35(N)?
 
Last edited:
Joshuava said:
This was copied directly from masteringphysics so I really can't answer that question...I just attempted to solve it as best I could, but my answer is not what it is looking for.
What is it looking for, then?
 
lep11 said:
What is it looking for, then?

I believe the question is looking for the amount of force that is exerted onto the trailer by the car. It wants the answer in 2 significant digits, and with my experience thus far, I don't imagine an answer would be 1.0E3(N)
 
Joshuava said:
I believe the question is looking for the amount of force that is exerted onto the trailer by the car.
Yes, but do you know what the answer should be? I got T≈1024N
 
Draw free-body diagrams for the car and trailer

Newton second
for Car F-T=mcar*a
for Trailer T-Fμ=mtrailer*a
they have equal acceleration a and T is the force the car exerts on the trailer or vice versa(Newton III) You don't even have to calculate a, just solve for T and substitute it into car equation.
 
Awesome, now I understand it all. Thanks so much for your help! By the way, I put in 1000 for the solution and it accepted it, even though it was asking for 2 sig figs.
 
Back
Top