Forces with direction and magnitude

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a physics problem involving forces acting on a particle. The forces F[1] and F[2] have specific magnitudes and directions, and the task is to calculate their Cartesian components and the total force acting on the particle.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the calculation of the Cartesian components of the forces and the total force. There is uncertainty about the method of resolving the forces and the concept of a couple. Questions arise regarding the interpretation of the problem and the relationship between the forces and the position of the particle.

Discussion Status

Participants are exploring different interpretations of the problem and questioning the calculations presented. Some guidance has been offered regarding the resolution of forces into components, but there is no explicit consensus on the correct approach or understanding of the terms used.

Contextual Notes

There is confusion regarding the reference to a "couple" and its implications for the forces acting on the particle. The original poster mentions a past paper, but details about the full question and any diagrams are missing, which may affect the clarity of the discussion.

dopey9
Messages
31
Reaction score
0
Forces/couple!

particle of mass m kilograms is acted on by two forces F[1] and F[2] with magnitudes 3*sqr-root 5 Newtons and sqr-root 5 Newtons and directions parallel to the vectors i+2j and i-2j respectively.
The particle is initially at a position given by the vector 2i+j

i was told to calculate the cartesian components of F[1] and F[2] and hence calculate the total force F[1] + F[2], acting on the particle in component form

MY SOLUTION

The vector i+ 2j has length sqrt{1^2+ 2^2}= sqrt{5}[
A vector in that direction, with length is just 3 times that: 3i+ 6j. That's the first force vector.
Similarly, the vector i- 2j also has length root5 so that is the second force vector. The total force, then, is F1+ F2= (3i+ 6j)+ (i- 2j)= 4i+4j

from there i need to show the couple of the total force about the point with position vector i is zero...so the total force is 4i+4j ......

I would appreaciate a explanation to how to tackle this Q, so I can do it myself...but I am assuming that it is a single force and a couple cannot be put in equilibrium by a single force so it must be zero? is that correct??
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
I'm not really sure where you are getting your calculations from. They might be right, but you would have to maybe explain them a little more because I don't really understand where you are getting things such as the length is just 3 times the slope of the force. The way I would approach the problem is to take your two forces and resolve them into component form, so {i_1; j_1; i_2; j_2}, and then add them together.
 
dopey9 said:
particle of mass m kilograms is acted on by two forces F[1] and F[2] with magnitudes 3*sqr-root 5 Newtons and sqr-root 5 Newtons and directions parallel to the vectors i+2j and i-2j respectively.
The particle is initially at a position given by the vector 2i+j

i was told to calculate the cartesian components of F[1] and F[2] and hence calculate the total force F[1] + F[2], acting on the particle in component form

MY SOLUTION

The vector i+ 2j has length sqrt{1^2+ 2^2}= sqrt{5}[
A vector in that direction, with length is just 3 times that: 3i+ 6j. That's the first force vector.
Similarly, the vector i- 2j also has length root5 so that is the second force vector. The total force, then, is F1+ F2= (3i+ 6j)+ (i- 2j)= 4i+4j
This all sounds correct to me
from there i need to show the couple of the total force about the point with position vector i is zero...so the total force is 4i+4j ......

This is where I am losing you. You said earlier that the particle is at the position 2i +j. So why are we talking about position "i" here?
And by
couple" what do you mean? The torque? I am not sure what 'couple" means.

I would appreaciate a explanation to how to tackle this Q, so I can do it myself...but I am assuming that it is a single force and a couple cannot be put in equilibrium by a single force so it must be zero? is that correct??
 
...

nrqed said:
This all sounds correct to me


This is where I am losing you. You said earlier that the particle is at the position 2i +j. So why are we talking about position "i" here?
And by
couple" what do you mean? The torque? I am not sure what 'couple" means.

but this is what i have taken from a past paper...it says "the couple of the total force about the point with position vector i is zero" ...its confusing me too...thankz for the help tho
 
dopey9 said:
but this is what i have taken from a past paper...it says "the couple of the total force about the point with position vector i is zero" ...its confusing me too...thankz for the help tho
Ok. By "past paper" do you mean it's a question taken from a book?!
Is there a drawing? Could you post the entire question as it is phrased there? Is this for an engineering class or a physics class? Have you covered torque?

I am asking all this simply because I wish I could be more helpful!

Patrick
 
nrqed said:
Ok. By "past paper" do you mean it's a question taken from a book?!
Is there a drawing? Could you post the entire question as it is phrased there? Is this for an engineering class or a physics class? Have you covered torque?

I am asking all this simply because I wish I could be more helpful!

Patrick

Dont worry about it ...iv left it out..thankz for help...but if u do want the full question ...the first one i posted...and the last one i jus posted ...and that's all i was given..there was no diagram thankz anyway
 
A couple is two equal and opposite forces times the perpindicular distance between them. Thus the body on which the couple acts will rotate, but not translate.
 
Last edited:
dopey9 said:
particle of mass m kilograms is acted on by two forces F[1] and F[2] with magnitudes 3*sqr-root 5 Newtons and sqr-root 5 Newtons and directions parallel to the vectors i+2j and i-2j respectively.
The particle is initially at a position given by the vector 2i+j

i was told to calculate the cartesian components of F[1] and F[2] and hence calculate the total force F[1] + F[2], acting on the particle in component form

Ok, I'm ignoring everything in the solution, although some of it indicates you're answering another question

To break a vector into cartesian components, first you need to know the angle of the vector with respect to the x-axis. You would do this by taking arctan(y/x) of the direction it's in (y=j component, x=i component). Once you know the angle (call it a), you can find the x and y components by doing fcos(a) and fsin(a). Then add them together (keep in mind one force has positive and one negative y direction)
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
2K
Replies
26
Views
3K
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
1K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
1K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K