Two objects are thrown from a cliff, one with a positive initial velocity (upward) and the other with a negative initial velocity (downward). The discussion centers on whether the object thrown upward reaches a greater height and thus has a larger final velocity (vf) upon hitting the ground due to a longer duration under gravity. It is pointed out that the initial velocities must be considered when calculating vf, as they influence the overall motion. The upward-thrown object will eventually return to the cliff's height, raising questions about its velocity at that point. Ultimately, the calculations of final velocities depend on both the initial velocities and the heights reached.