Graphite's delocalised electron?

  • Thread starter Thread starter pivoxa15
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Electron
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
2 replies · 15K views
pivoxa15
Messages
2,250
Reaction score
1
They say 3 of graphite's electrons are covalently bonded and the other one is delocalised. But it shares among the other carbon atoms as well as having it itself because no carbon atom is charged in graphite. But that means it is very much covalent in nature? Why not have a double bond somewhere to explain the extra delocalised electron in every carbon atom in graphite? Or is it the case that they want to say that this electron is not fixed so can double bond with any of the three neighbouring carbon atoms?

Is that different to saying it forms a double bond since a double bond in reality means a reasonance structure where the bonding is not fixed anyway.
 
Last edited:
Chemistry news on Phys.org
pivoxa15 said:
They say 3 of graphite's electrons are covalently bonded and the other one is delocalised. But it shares among the other carbon atoms as well as having it itself because no carbon atom is charged in graphite. But that means it is very much covalent in nature? Why not have a double bond somewhere to explain the extra delocalised electron in every carbon atom in graphite? Or is it the case that they want to say that this electron is not fixed so can double bond with any of the three neighbouring carbon atoms?

Is that different to saying it forms a double bond since a double bond in reality means a reasonance structure where the bonding is not fixed anyway.
Did you study Benzene? It's the same principle. To see the resonance as an alternating formation of single/double bonds is not exact. Actually the electrons forms an entire molecular bond, that is, it is effectively delocalized in all the molecule, that is, the electronic "cloud" is made of two doghnuts over the plane of the molecule, on opposite sides.

In graphite, all the Benzene rings become one, in this sense: the electrons are delocalized in all the plane of the molecules, above and under.
Many planes of molecules = many layers.
 
pivoxa15 said:
But that means it is very much covalent in nature? Why not have a double bond somewhere to explain the extra delocalised electron in every carbon atom in graphite?
Because covalent bonds (including double bonds) are localized in nature.

Is that different to saying it forms a double bond since a double bond in reality means a reasonance structure where the bonding is not fixed anyway.
A double bond is not a resonance hybrid. It is, an approximation based on overlap of localized, independent atomic orbitals (typically, but not necessarily, one sigma overlap and one pi overlap).

("Independent" means that I can write the many-electron wavefunction as a product of many single-particle wavefunctions).
 
Last edited: