Gravity on air molecule vs. diffusion into vacuum

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the forces that keep Earth's atmosphere intact, primarily gravity, which holds air molecules close to the planet. Diffusion is mentioned as a process that allows air to move into a vacuum, but it is clarified that diffusion itself is not a force but a consequence of existing forces. The conversation seeks a simple proof of how Earth's gravity prevents atmospheric escape, beyond mere observation. The participant expresses curiosity about the physics involved, particularly in relation to how air can leak into vacuum chambers, questioning why the same does not happen on a larger scale with Earth's atmosphere. The aim is to understand the balance of forces that maintain the atmosphere against the tendency for diffusion into space.
houlahound
Messages
907
Reaction score
223
OK the atmosphere by definition envelopes the earth.The force keeping it here is solely gravity.

The "force" opposing this is diffusion across a pressure gradient into the vacuum of space.

Assuming that is correct how could I prove this other than looking out the window.

Newton's law of gravity will give the force Earth exerts on a single molecule, the force of the vacuum??
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The force keeping it here is solely gravity. yes

The "force" opposing this is diffusion across a pressure gradient into the vacuum of space.
Diffusion isn't really a force; it's more the consequence of a force. But I understand what you mean.

What kind of proof did you have in mind ? A derivation of the http://acmg.seas.harvard.edu/people/faculty/djj/book/bookchap2.html probably isn't what you mean, or is it ?

[edit] made a quote of the quote
 
Last edited:
A proof that is self evident and not too hard-core in the math.
 
But what is it you want to prove ?
 
That the Earth's atmosphere sticks to the earth.

Other than just breathing the proof.

The question is motivated by many, many...many years ago as an undergrad I used to hang out in the postgrad e2e collision lab and saw the engineering involved to keep in gassing of the atmosphere screwing up the low vacuum chambers enclosing the experiments.

I figure if air can leak into those elaborate chambers to be such a measurable problem then what's the physics stopping same air leaking out of the wall-less chamber of the earth.

I get we exist therefore we have an atmosphere, I just want to get the physics of the opposing "forces".
 
Last edited:
Back
Top