Gravity vs Diffusion: Contradiction or Reality?

  • Thread starter Thread starter wasteofo2
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Diffusion Gravity
AI Thread Summary
The discussion addresses the confusion surrounding the relationship between diffusion and gravity. It clarifies that Newton's law of gravity has minimal impact on the behavior of small particles, as their gravitational attraction is negligible. Instead, the motion and collisions of particles are the primary drivers of diffusion, leading to their tendency to spread out. The conversation also raises a question about the mass threshold at which gravity begins to dominate over diffusion. Overall, the dynamics of particle interactions are more influenced by kinetic energy and collisions than by gravitational forces.
wasteofo2
Messages
477
Reaction score
2
The concept of diffusion is confusing me, as it seems to contradict gravity.

x = particles of matter with a mass of 1
| = a barrier particle x can permeate

Situation A:
xxxxx|x


(1)In my biology class, we're told, and do experiments to prove that, in this situation, the result will be:


Result of Situation A (tested approximately)
xxx|xxx


The explanation of this is that the particles are simply too tightly packed and want to expand.


(2)However, Newtons law of gravity would show that the 5x's would attract the 1x with a force 5 times greater than the 1x would attract the 5x's(I think). Therefore, in order to equal out(3x's per side), wouldn't the 1x need to pull twice as hard on the 5x's? Doesn't Newtons law of gravity show that the result of that experiment would tend towards the side with 5x's at least keeping all of it's particles, if not gaining the 1x?

Oh god I'm so confused...
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Newton's law of gravity has nothing to do with this- the gravitational pull of one small particle on another is almost nil.
One crucial point is that the particles are all in motion (air molecules or molecules suspended in water), a little more precise than "want to expand" is that the molecules collide with each other. The closer the molecules are packed the more collisions and the more they bounce away from one another, thus "spreading out".
 
Originally posted by HallsofIvy
Newton's law of gravity has nothing to do with this- the gravitational pull of one small particle on another is almost nil.
One crucial point is that the particles are all in motion (air molecules or molecules suspended in water), a little more precise than "want to expand" is that the molecules collide with each other. The closer the molecules are packed the more collisions and the more they bounce away from one another, thus "spreading out".

If the force of such small particles upon each other is negligable:

1.) At what approx. mass does gravity take precedence over diffusion?
 
Back
Top