Help in switching from physics to math

  • Thread starter Thread starter quasar_4
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Physics
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a student's poor performance on the physics GRE and their contemplation of switching from physics to mathematics for graduate studies. They express uncertainty about how a low physics GRE score might affect their application if they perform well on the math GRE. The student is particularly interested in the differences between mathematical physics and physics from a mathematician's perspective, especially regarding their passion for gravitational physics and the math involved in general relativity. They highlight their strong background in various math courses, including differential geometry and abstract algebra, while noting a lack of exposure to topology. The student seeks advice on their potential transition to math and the nature of research in the field.
quasar_4
Messages
273
Reaction score
0
So, as I kind of expected, after not studying much for the physics subject GRE I did very badly, ~20th percentile. I'm still applying to some schools, but with limited hope. I now have to decide - I can do a year-long MS in physics or math, then retake the subject GRE. I'm thinking about changing to math (not sure yet), because I'm slightly better at it, but have some questions:

1) will it hurt to have bombed the physics GRE if I do okay on the math GRE in a year? or, since it was physics, will it not really matter at all?
2) how different is mathematical physics for a mathematician than it is for a physicist? I was planning to to gravitational physics, but it's specifically the math in GR that excites and drives me, so I am pretty sure I'd be happy doing math. But I'm not sure how different the emphasis is, and also, all my research has been more from the physics side, so I'm not sure what research in math is like or if I'd be good at it. I think I can handle math classes; I have taken some graduate math classes as an undergrad and immensely enjoyed them.

And also, I don't need any responses telling me to give up because I'm not smart enough. There is a tendency for people to do that on these forums. I am quite smart enough, just didn't spend the time necessary to prepare. (And I hadn't taken several core classes when I took the physics GRE, so I think that's part of the score as well).
 
Physics news on Phys.org
A few questions for you! What kind of math have you taken? And what kind of math are you interested in? (I don't know much... well hardly any physics so "math in GR" means nothing to me ;) )
 
Let's see, in terms of upper div. courses (you know, past all the requirements for calculus, linear algebra, ODEs, etc.), I have had:

Undergraduate level -

Differential Geometry - A
Abstract Algebra- A
Modern Algebra (Groups + Galois theory) - A
Linear Algebra - A
Intro. Analysis - B
Real Analysis I - still waiting, but I think an A- or B+.

Graduate level -

Differential Geometry - taking this spring
Multilinear Algebra and Representation Theory - A

I also got an A in a physics class this semester called "Methods of Theoretical Physics" - we covered come topics from complex analysis including Cauchy's integral formula and contour integrals, ODE's (solutions with power series, Green's functions, etc.), PDE's (method of characteristics, sep. of variables, etc.), more linear algebra, special functions (Bessel, Legendre, Hermite, etc.), so at this point I feel like I've been exposed to a lot.

Except Topology, because it hasn't been offered at my school since I declared myself as a math major!

I REALLY love differential geometry and algebra. Basically, linear/abstract algebra and group theory are wonderful, and they appear everywhere. Linear algebra is also a foundation of differential geometry, so maybe that is why I like geometry so much. I love how it relates to things in physics, especially in general relativity (this is what I meant by GR!). I will say that I didn't much enjoy doing Galois theory problems, but the theory is interesting. And we didn't cover much representation theory in my one class (only made it a small way into Fulton & Harris's book, but it was interesting too).
 
TL;DR Summary: What topics to cover to safely say I know arithmetic ? I am learning arithmetic from Indian NCERT textbook. Currently I have finished addition ,substraction of 2 digit numbers and divisions, multiplication of 1 digit numbers. I am moving pretty slowly. Can someone tell me what topics to cover first to build a framework and then go on in detail. I want to learn fast. It has taken me a year now learning arithmetic. I want to speed up. Thanks for the help in advance. (I also...
Hi community My aim is to get into research about atoms, specifically, I want to do experimental research that explores questions like: 1. Why do Gallium/Mercury have low melting points 2. Why are there so many exceptions and inconsistencies when it comes to explaining molecular structures / reaction mechanisms in inorganic and organic chemistry 3. Experimental research about fundamental Quantum Mechanics, such as the one being followed by Hiroshima university that proved that observing...
I am currently in the second (and final) year of my MS in Physics. I've just started my research, which focuses on identifying Dark Matter through Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) extensions. My supervisor has directed me to learn model building using FeynRules and subsequent calculations via MadGraph or other simulators. I've successfully built models for QED and QCD, and I am now working on Weak Interactions, Electroweak theory, and symmetry breaking. My immediate goal for the next few...

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
4K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
36
Views
4K
Replies
12
Views
2K
Back
Top