Here be monsters (Orcas sinking boats on purpose)

  • Thread starter Frabjous
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Animals
In summary, orcas have been sinking boats in Europe and appear to be teaching others to do the same. This behavior is likely due to their intelligence and ability to effectively hunt in packs. There is also concern for the safety of these orcas, as they are an endangered species. The reason for their interest in boats is still unknown, but some theories suggest they may mistake them for prey or are retaliating against perceived threats.
Biology news on Phys.org
  • #3
Effective pack hunters, exhibit some sophisticated co-operative behaviour.

I remember watching this.



A quick google, they can be six tonnes and 26 feet long apparently, Great whites are about 20 ft and two tonnes max just for comparison.

Same family as dolphins so intelligent too.

Hopefully, it is just a fad as the article mentioned.

From wiki.

“Some local populations are considered threatened or endangered due to prey depletion, habitat loss, pollution (by PCBs), capture for marine mammal parks, and conflicts with human fisheries.

In late 2005, the southern resident orcas, which swim in British Columbia and Washington waters, were placed on the U.S. Endangered Species list.”
 
  • Like
Likes BillTre, Astranut and Frabjous
  • #4
Hornbein said:
The article says they are destroying rudders, the sinking is a side effect that happened in a few cases.
The rudder is the most fragile part of most sailboats. The rudder is sometimes attached only to a metal tube that passes through the hull and is sometimes not well supported. A collision might easily bend the tube and disrupt the seal which is sometimes hard to access to repair a leak. Even keels can be suspect especially when there is too much optimism in new technology used for support/mounting/fastening and it is pushed too far.

Why the orcas have an interest in the boats is interesting. I wonder as some suggest that the particular orca had some experience with one resulting in an interest. A sailboat's underwater shape is very fish-like some more than others. Since orcas like shark livers could this "attack" be due to the fact the size, shape, and color resembled a great white? I would be interested in the color of the underwater hull since white or gray might make it look like a shark.
 
  • Informative
Likes pinball1970
  • #5
gleem said:
The rudder is the most fragile part of most sailboats. The rudder is sometimes attached only to a metal tube that passes through the hull and is sometimes not well supported. A collision might easily bend the tube and disrupt the seal which is sometimes hard to access to repair a leak. Even keels can be suspect especially when there is too much optimism in new technology used for support/mounting/fastening and it is pushed too far.

Why the orcas have an interest in the boats is interesting. I wonder as some suggest that the particular orca had some experience with one resulting in an interest. A sailboat's underwater shape is very fish-like some more than others. Since orcas like shark livers could this "attack" be due to the fact the size, shape, and color resembled a great white? I would be interested in the color of the underwater hull since white or gray might make it look like a shark.
Possible they are teaching their young where to bite a shark to get its liver using a ship that doesn't bite back. More likely IMO (given their intellect) maybe someone in the family got hit because the sail boats are quiet, and they are simply "fed up" retaliating against a perceived threat.
 

1. Why have there been reports of orcas sinking boats?

Orcas, also known as killer whales, are highly intelligent and social creatures. The reports of orcas interacting aggressively with boats, including sinking them, could be due to a variety of reasons. Some scientists speculate that these interactions may be playful behavior misinterpreted as aggression, or it could be a defensive response to threats perceived by the orcas from the boats. Another theory suggests that orcas might be reacting to previous negative experiences with boats or feeling threatened by their presence in their natural habitats.

2. Are these incidents of orcas sinking boats common?

Incidents of orcas sinking boats are relatively rare. While there have been several notable reports, especially in regions like the coasts of Spain and Portugal, these events are not common when considering the global population of orcas and the vast areas they inhabit. Most interactions between orcas and humans are either neutral or positive, with orcas often displaying curiosity rather than aggression.

3. What should boaters do to avoid negative encounters with orcas?

Boaters should maintain a respectful distance from all marine wildlife, including orcas. It is advisable to follow guidelines and regulations set by wildlife authorities, which often include keeping a minimum distance from the animals and avoiding rapid changes in speed or direction. If orcas appear to be approaching, it is recommended to slow down and steer the boat in a way that minimizes disturbance, and if safe, to stop the boat until the orcas have passed.

4. How do researchers study orca behavior in relation to boats?

Researchers study orca behavior using various methods including tagging, drone observations, and acoustic monitoring. Tagging allows scientists to track the movements and behavior of individual orcas. Drone footage provides a bird’s-eye view of orca interactions without disturbing them. Acoustic monitoring helps in understanding the communication and response of orcas to various stimuli, including the presence of boats. These studies help in gathering data on how orcas react to human activities and contribute to developing strategies to mitigate negative interactions.

5. What impact do these aggressive behaviors have on orca populations?

Aggressive behaviors toward boats could potentially have negative impacts on orca populations if they lead to stricter regulations limiting human interaction or if they alter the public's perception of these animals. Additionally, such behaviors could be indicative of stress or distress among orca populations, possibly due to human activity or environmental changes. Understanding these behaviors is crucial for conservation efforts and ensuring that both human and orca populations can coexist safely.

Similar threads

  • Biology and Medical
Replies
1
Views
793
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
4K
Replies
16
Views
3K
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
0
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Biology and Medical
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Mechanics
Replies
7
Views
4K
Back
Top