Suggestion How about a 'Like' Button for Posts?

[I_am_learning]

This just clicked in my mind, and I am sharing it right off.
In our forum lots of people are trying to help. But people aren't always good at helping. In fact they are also posting wrong suggestion, although, the wrong posts are often corrected at later posts by the same member or by other, it rarely occurs that the wrong post is edited. And if the thread is particularly long, unsuspecting reader who is lazy to read all of the thread may sometimes get totally wrong knowledge.

If there was some way to rate posts by simple polling by viewers like the familiar Facebook like, and unfamiliar Dislike, then I think it would be awesome.
What do you think?

 

[micromass]

I don't really like this suggestion. This way, PF will become something like yahoo answers, where the bad answers might get liked more. And this shouldn't happen.

The good thing about PF is that incorrect answers are swiftly corrected by knowledgeable members (and blatantly false answers get deleted). So if you want the correct information, you will get it eventually. You just need to read all the answers.

 

[Ryan_m_b]

I don't really like this suggestion. This way, PF will become something like yahoo answers, where the bad answers might get liked more. And this shouldn't happen.

The good thing about PF is that incorrect answers are swiftly corrected by knowledgeable members (and blatantly false answers get deleted). So if you want the correct information, you will get it eventually. You just need to read all the answers.

Definitely. Above all this is a science forum, the best answers are the right ones. If we have a like/dislike feature (or any kind of ranking system for that matter) we run the risk of creating a popularity contest. We wouldn't want people posting with reward in mind, similarly we wouldn't want people not to post for fear of negative votes. I'd also hate to think how this system would work in a forum like P&WA!

 

[Evo]

This just clicked in my mind, and I am sharing it right off.
In our forum lots of people are trying to help. But people aren't always good at helping. In fact they are also posting wrong suggestion, although, the wrong posts are often corrected at later posts by the same member or by other, it rarely occurs that the wrong post is edited. And if the thread is particularly long, unsuspecting reader who is lazy to read all of the thread may sometimes get totally wrong knowledge.

I don't know that we have enough mentor resources to actively go back and edit the original of posts that have been corrected. It's really up to the member to decide how valuable getting the right information is by skimming down the thread. I know sometimes there is so much *noise* that it can be difficult if the thread is long.

If there was some way to rate posts by simple polling by viewers like the familiar Facebook like, and unfamiliar Dislike, then I think it would be awesome.
What do you think?

We do have a system to show which members have been acknowledged for giving consistantly accurate and helpful advice, it is the Science Advisor and Homework Helper medals. When you see someone with one of these recognitions, you can be pretty sure the information is usually accurate (anyone can make a mistake).

 

[Evo]

Definitely. Above all this is a science forum, the best answers are the right ones. If we have a like/dislike feature (or any kind of ranking system for that matter) we run the risk of creating a popularity contest. We wouldn't want people posting with reward in mind, similarly we wouldn't want people not to post for fear of negative votes. I'd also hate to think how this system would work in a forum like P&WA!

(bolding mine)

 

[Ryan_m_b]

(bolding mine)

***Ryan Likes Evo's Post ***

 

[I_am_learning]

I got it.
Yeah, I don't want the 'Like' button now. Suggestion Withdrawn. :)
But, still some sort of warning sign on clearly wrong posts should benefit all, especially those who are redirected by Google.
But it must be such that the warning sign can only be given by mentors.
I know its not much necessary, because its the reader's responsibility to read it all, but still I am saving myself some room in this thread. :)

 

[diazona]

This is basically the system that the Stack Exchange network uses - not actually a "like" button, but upvote and downvote buttons. It actually works pretty well, as long as the site is controlled enough to keep out the really bad questions that get posted on places like Yahoo Answers.

 

[Pengwuino]

How can I dislike the entire P&WA forum?

 

[lisab]

I got it.
Yeah, I don't want the 'Like' button now. Suggestion Withdrawn. :)
But, still some sort of warning sign on clearly wrong posts should benefit all, especially those who are redirected by Google.
But it must be such that the warning sign can only be given by mentors.
I know its not much necessary, because its the reader's responsibility to read it all, but still I am saving myself some room in this thread. :)

If you see a post that is clearly wrong, you should report it. The mentors do a great job, but they need as many extra eyes as they can get!

 

[lisab]

How can I dislike the entire P&WA forum?

How about a feather-pluck button?

 

[dlgoff]

I got it.
Yeah, I don't want the 'Like' button now. Suggestion Withdrawn. :)
But, still some sort of warning sign on clearly wrong posts should benefit all, especially those who are redirected by Google.
But it must be such that the warning sign can only be given by mentors.
I know its not much necessary, because its the reader's responsibility to read it all, but still I am saving myself some room in this thread. :)

If you see a post that is clearly wrong, you should report it. The mentors do a great job, but they need as many extra eyes as they can get!

When I've made mistakes and catch it after posting (not spelling errors), I put an edit note explaining. If someone else post an answer that shows theirs is correct or is a better alternative, I do a follow up post stating my incorrectness or that my alternative is not as good.

 

[Redbelly98]

How about a feather-pluck button?

Not while I'M a Mentor

 

[lisab]

Not while I'M a Mentor