How Do You Solve for Voltage U in a Simple DC Circuit with Series Components?

5 replies · 2K views · last reply
Zrpeip
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Hi everyone, first post.
Just wanted to say I've been using parts of this forum for a long time for help in understanding all kinds of concepts, and have found it immensely helpful over the years. Thank you for all of your contributions!
So, here goes with my hopefully very simple question:

Homework Statement



From a practice exam with answer key.
Written: 'What is the value of the voltage U?'
The drawing: a simple closed loop with 3 circuit elements in series (from top to bottom on one side): an ideal voltage source U_0 (positive terminal 'on top'), a resistor R, and an ideal current source I_0 (current emerges 'on top').
The voltage in question U appears across two terminal legs placed above and below the ideal current source, and has the same orientation as the voltage source (i.e. positive terminal 'on top').
I've attached a picture as well.


Homework Equations



I used KVL in the main loop (clockwise):
-U_0 + R*I_0 -U = 0


The Attempt at a Solution



The above equation gave me my solution, or so I thought. U = R*I_0 - U_0.
However, the listed solution is U = R*I_0 + U_0.

I would assume that R*I_0 and U_0, written symbolically as they are in this problem, could never have the same sign (following the KVL loop and polarities).

But I don't feel that I understand how to treat voltages across ideal current sources anyway. So perhaps my problem is there. I would appreciate any explanation of how to approach that in general as well.

I'm still a beginner and make dumb mistakes in circuit analysis all the time and root most of them out eventually, but for whatever reason I'm not getting it here. I think I've overthought it. Thanks in advance!
 
Attachments
  • Circuit schematic: a voltage source U0 with an arrow and a resistor R in series, above an ideal current source I0; terminals on the left are labelled U with a downward arrow.
    Voltage across ideal current source.PNG
    1.6 KB · Views: 614
Try to draw the circuit in this way
 
Attachments
  • Two circuit schematics joined by an equals sign: the left has a voltage source U0 in series with resistor R and current source I0 with voltage U, the right shows an equivalent with current source I0 and voltage U, resistor R and voltage source U0 in parallel.
    Voltage across ideal current source.PNG
    3 KB · Views: 623
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: 1 person
Thanks for your reply, Jony130 :-) The drawing is helpful to me, didn't even think of redrawing it. Now I have a new technique to use when I get stuck.

But even after trying that, I (think I) still have the same question.

Let me write out how I'm thinking about it from your drawing:
For KVL loop in main loop, I make my loop clockwise starting between the resistor and voltage source:
Voltage across voltage source: -U_0
Voltage across terminals (voltage across current source): -U
Voltage across resistor: +R*I_0
Total KVL equation: -U_0 + R*I_0 -U = 0
Add U to both sides, I get my answer: U = R*I_0 MINUS U_0

The solution in the answer key: U = R*I_0 PLUS U_0
Both R*I_0 and U_0 in the final equation are positive and I don't see why yet.

(sorry for the bolding, I don't want to be rude but I just wanted to make my question clearer)
Thanks
 
I mark the component polarities

Circuit schematic with a current source I0 and a voltage source U0 in series with resistor R between two horizontal wires, with a circulating loop current arrow and labelled terminal voltage U.


So we have Uo - U + Io*R = 0


Or

- Uo + U - Io*R = 0
 
Attachments
  • Circuit schematic with a current source I0 and a voltage source U0 in series with resistor R, with current and voltage polarity markings and a loop arrow.
    source.PNG
    1.8 KB · Views: 571
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: 1 person
Thank you again :-)
I'm in Germany and here, as far as I know, the arrow on a voltage source is actually opposite polarity to what you have drawn (tail at + end and tip at - end)... so we still have the same problem.
 
You mark the direction of a current source in clockwise direction. And this means that the voltage at point A must be higher then the voltage at point B (Io*R higher ).
Circuit schematic: a current source I0 with an upward arrow in a vertical branch on the left, in series with a resistor R and a voltage source U0 on the right, with nodes A, B and C labelled.

So from this we can say that the voltage at point A is equal to:
Va = Vb + (Io*R) = Uo + VR. And the voltage at current source is
Vac = Va - Vb = (Uo + VR) - 0V = Uo + VR because we treat Vc as our reference point (GND).

But if we reverse the direction of a current source we have this situation
Circuit schematic: a current source I0 on the left branch between a top wire and bottom wire, in series with a resistor R and voltage source U0 on the right branch, with nodes labelled A, B and C.

And now the voltage at point A is Io*R lower then the voltage at point B.
So Vac = Vo - Io*R

Zrpeip said:
Thank you again :-)
I'm in Germany and here, as far as I know, the arrow on a voltage source is actually opposite polarity to what you have drawn (tail at + end and tip at - end)... so we still have the same problem.
In my drawings the arrow tip points to the most positive end (highest potential) of the component.
OK so for your polarity we have this situation
Circuit schematic with a current source I0 on the left branch and a resistor R in series with voltage source U0 on the right branch, with nodes labelled A, B and C.


We treat point C as our GND (reference point).
The voltage at point B is equal to -Vo and the voltage at point A is Io*R higher the the voltage at point b.
Vac = Vb + Io*R = -Vo + Io*R
 
Attachments
  • Circuit schematic with a current source I0 on the left branch and a series branch on the right containing resistor R between node A and node B, and voltage source U0 below B, with node C at the bottom.
    source2.PNG
    1.9 KB · Views: 565
  • Circuit schematic: a current source I0 with an upward arrow in a vertical branch, in series with a resistor R and a voltage source U0 between nodes A (top, red) and C (bottom, blue), with node B between R and U0.
    source.PNG
    2 KB · Views: 573
  • Circuit schematic: a current source I0 in a left branch between a top wire to node A and a bottom wire to node C, with a resistor R and voltage source U0 in series in the right branch, node B between them.
    source3.PNG
    1.7 KB · Views: 617
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: 1 person