How does light from the sun cause atoms to vibrate?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion centers around the mechanisms by which sunlight causes atoms to vibrate, leading to the generation of heat in materials such as brick and metal. Participants explore concepts related to energy absorption, heat transfer, and the role of molecular vibrations in the context of physics and thermodynamics.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants propose that the movement of electrons from a stable to an excited state is a key factor in how light transforms into heat.
  • Others argue that it is the molecules of the brick that absorb photons, increasing their kinetic energy and causing vibrations, which we perceive as heat.
  • A later reply discusses the concept of radiationless transitions, suggesting that atoms can transition from electronically excited states to vibrationally excited states, contributing to the overall heat of the material.
  • Some participants question the clarity of terms and mechanisms used in the discussion, expressing confusion about how light generates heat and the specifics of molecular vibrations.
  • There is mention of the three forms of heat transfer: conduction, convection, and radiation, with examples provided to illustrate these concepts.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of views on the mechanisms of heat generation from light, with no consensus reached on the specifics of how light causes atomic vibrations. Some participants challenge the clarity and validity of certain claims made in the discussion.

Contextual Notes

There are unresolved questions regarding the definitions and assumptions related to molecular vibrations and energy transitions. Some participants express a lack of background in physics, which may influence their understanding of the concepts discussed.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be of interest to individuals exploring the relationship between light and heat, particularly in the context of materials science, thermodynamics, and energy transfer mechanisms.

PrayingMantis
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Is the reason behind the vibrating the movement of electrons from a stable to a excited state?

My quest for knowledge began with this question..."How exactly does light transform into heat--for instance, when sunlight warms up a brick wall? I understand that electrons in the atoms in the wall absorb the light, but how does that absorbed sunlight turn into thermal energy?"

I later found out that the atoms are perpetually vibrating due to the resonance of the solar energy. Soon enough, the vibration causes atoms to collide and heat. But, how does light cause the vibration of the atoms?
 
Last edited:
Science news on Phys.org
PrayingMantis said:
Is the reason behind the vibrating the movement of electrons from a stable to a excited state?

My quest for knowledge began with this question..."How exactly does light transform into heat--for instance, when sunlight warms up a brick wall? I understand that electrons in the atoms in the wall absorb the light, but how does that absorbed sunlight turn into thermal energy?"

I later found out that the atoms are perpetually vibrating due to the resonance of the solar energy. Soon enough, the vibration causes atoms to collide and heat. But, how does light cause the vibration of the atoms?

First of all, it is the molecules of the brick that absorb the photons of sunshine, not the electrons. Photons are massless parcels of electromagnetic energy. When absorbed by a molecule, the photon ceases to exist and the kinetic energy of the molecule increases. When the mean kinetic energy of a large number of molecules is increased, we sense this as an increase in temperature.

Kinetic energy can be of three kinds: translation (movement of the molecule from place to place), rotation along any or all of the molecule's axes of rotation, and vibration/libration. For solids, such as brick, most of the kinetic energy is vibration/libration. The brick, in its turn, will emit photons at thermal infrared wavelengths. We sense this radiation as sensible heat.

In this manner, electromagnetic energy (light) becomes sensible heat.
 
klimatos said:
First of all, it is the molecules of the brick that absorb the photons of sunshine, not the electrons. Photons are massless parcels of electromagnetic energy. When absorbed by a molecule, the photon ceases to exist and the kinetic energy of the molecule increases. When the mean kinetic energy of a large number of molecules is increased, we sense this as an increase in temperature.

Kinetic energy can be of three kinds: translation (movement of the molecule from place to place), rotation along any or all of the molecule's axes of rotation, and vibration/libration. For solids, such as brick, most of the kinetic energy is vibration/libration. The brick, in its turn, will emit photons at thermal infrared wavelengths. We sense this radiation as sensible heat.

In this manner, electromagnetic energy (light) becomes sensible heat.
In my textbook, it states that the electrons absorb the light and cause it to become 'excited'. Electrons in a excited state are rather unstable so in a few nanoseconds would return to ground state. Then, it says that heat is released. Is it the emission of photons that causes the brick to be hot once touched? I really appreciate you answering by the way.
 
Last edited:
PrayingMantis said:
Is it the emission of photons that causes the brick to be hot once touched? I really appreciate you answering by the way.

Mm. Yes and no.

There are three forms of heat transfer: radiation, conduction and convection.

When you touch the bricks, that's conduction. The molecules of the brick are directly transferring kinetic energy to the molecules of your hand.

If you feel heat from the bricks without touching them, that's partly convection (bricks heat air, air brings heat to your hand) and partly radiation (bricks radiate infrared photons, which strike your hand).
 
DaveC426913 said:
Mm. Yes and no.

There are three forms of heat transfer: radiation, conduction and convection.

When you touch the bricks, that's conduction. The molecules of the brick are directly transferring kinetic energy to the molecules of your hand.

If you feel heat from the bricks without touching them, that's partly convection (bricks heat air, air brings heat to your hand) and partly radiation (bricks radiate infrared photons, which strike your hand).

I have a question related to this paragraph. What causes the atoms to vibrate?"Light from the sun excites electrons in the atoms which constitute the brick wall. How does that electronic energy get converted to heat, you ask. The key is 'radiationless transitions.' Here's how it works: the atoms of the brick are perpetually vibrating. Some of those atoms vibrate sufficiently vigorously that their vibrational energy is roughly equal to the electronic energy (photons) absorbed from the sun--in essence, they are in resonance with the solar energy. Those atoms then make a quantum transition from 'electronically excited' to 'vibrationally excited,' meaning that the energy causes the whole atom to move. We feel that motion as "heat." The atoms which make the jump to vibrational excitation soon collide into neighboring atoms, dissipating their vibrational energy throughout the entire brick, making the brick hot throughout.
 
PrayingMantis said:
I have a question related to this paragraph. What causes the atoms to vibrate?"Light from the sun excites electrons in the atoms which constitute the brick wall. How does that electronic energy get converted to heat, you ask. The key is 'radiationless transitions.' Here's how it works: the atoms of the brick are perpetually vibrating. Some of those atoms vibrate sufficiently vigorously that their vibrational energy is roughly equal to the electronic energy (photons) absorbed from the sun--in essence, they are in resonance with the solar energy. Those atoms then make a quantum transition from 'electronically excited' to 'vibrationally excited,' meaning that the energy causes the whole atom to move. We feel that motion as "heat." The atoms which make the jump to vibrational excitation soon collide into neighboring atoms, dissipating their vibrational energy throughout the entire brick, making the brick hot throughout.
You say you have a question, then you proceed to make claims.

You're using terms and mechanisms that make no sense. We have a policy here about speculation and personal theories.
 
DaveC426913 said:
You say you have a question, then you proceed to make claims.

You're using terms and mechanisms that make no sense. We have a policy here about speculation and personal theories.

I'm sorry, I have no physics background. I was told to come here from a biology forum because it was more physics related. While looking for an answer to my original question, this result (the paragraph) came up from what seemed to be a reliable source. I do understand the three forms of heat transfer, but I do not understand how light can generate heat. What makes a car that's been sitting in a parking lot day hot? Light causes the molecules that constitute the car to vibrate which creates heat. That's a fact. What I want to know is what makes the molecules vibrate to begin with.
 
PrayingMantis said:
I'm sorry, I have no physics background. I was told to come here from a biology forum because it was more physics related. While looking for an answer to my original question, this result (the paragraph) came up from what seemed to be a reliable source. I do understand the three forms of heat transfer, but I do not understand how light can generate heat. What makes a car that's been sitting in a parking lot day hot? Light causes the molecules that constitute the car to vibrate which creates heat. That's a fact. What I want to know is what makes the molecules vibrate to begin with.

In any solid substance there will always be a distribution of molecular energies of vibration, from the base level to extremely vigorous. In a molecule, these vibratory energies include electrons moving rhythmically in and out along their bonding axes (vibration) and the flexing back and forth of these bonding axes (libration). In addition, the atoms of the molecule do the same two things relative to one another. The total of these energies is the total kinetic energy of vibration/libration.

The mean value of this kinetic energy distribution will be measured as temperature. When light is absorbed and its electromagnetic energy transformed into kinetic energy, the mean value of the energy distribution increases. We sense this as an increase in temperature.
The absorption of EMR does not start the molecules vibrating, it simply increases the mean energy level of this vibration.
 
klimatos said:
In any solid substance there will always be a distribution of molecular energies of vibration, from the base level to extremely vigorous. In a molecule, these vibratory energies include electrons moving rhythmically in and out along their bonding axes (vibration) and the flexing back and forth of these bonding axes (libration). In addition, the atoms of the molecule do the same two things relative to one another. The total of these energies is the total kinetic energy of vibration/libration.

The mean value of this kinetic energy distribution will be measured as temperature. When light is absorbed and its electromagnetic energy transformed into kinetic energy, the mean value of the energy distribution increases. We sense this as an increase in temperature.
The absorption of EMR does not start the molecules vibrating, it simply increases the mean energy level of this vibration.
thanks :smile: You cleared a lot of things up for me. May I ask though, HOW does it increase the mean energy level? Is there a scientific explanation behind it, or is it just accepted that it does?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • · Replies 49 ·
2
Replies
49
Views
5K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
12K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
2K