How Does the Sun's Power Output Compare to a Car Battery?

  • Thread starter Thread starter seto6
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Star Wattage
AI Thread Summary
The discussion compares the power output of the sun's interior to that of a car battery, revealing that the sun produces approximately 0.2 milliwatts per kilogram, while a car battery generates about 190 watts per kilogram, making the battery significantly more powerful. For part B, participants are encouraged to estimate the total energy output over the respective lifetimes of both the sun and the battery, with the sun's expected lifetime being around 5 billion years and the battery's about 3 years. The key focus is on calculating the energy in kilowatt-hours (kWh) to determine which source provides more energy over its lifetime. Participants express confusion about the calculations and seek clarification on how to approach part B. The conversation highlights the vast difference in energy output and longevity between the two sources.
seto6
Messages
248
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


A) How many W does 1 kg of the sun’s interior produce via nuclear reactions, on average? Compare the sun with a carbattery, which typically produces 190 W/kg. Which body wins?

B) Estimating the time the two objects are providing their respective power, compare the energy in kWh that 1kg of the two objects emit over their lifetime (one discharge time in case of the battery). Which object wins thiscompetition?

C) Assuming that the total radiated energy remains the same (it depends on the initial amount of hydrogen that willeventually convert to helium), what would be the main-sequence lifetime of the sun if it produced as much wattageper unit mass as the battery? Would life on Earth exist then? Would life anywhere else in the solar system exist?

Homework Equations



not sure

The Attempt at a Solution


for part i A) did solar luminosity/solarmass=0.2millwatt/kg so for 1kg is 0.2milliwatt and for care batt is 190w...so car wins...

for part B) not sure what to do hints would be great.. I am not under standing it...
EDIT: or can someone explain the part B because I am not under standing it.!

part C) i can do after part B..
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
anyone?
 
kinda urgent. I am not understanding what the question B is asking since i don't know thw life times
 
hints are welcomed
 
seto6 said:

Homework Statement


A) How many W does 1 kg of the sun’s interior produce via nuclear reactions, on average? Compare the sun with a carbattery, which typically produces 190 W/kg. Which body wins?

B) Estimating the time the two objects are providing their respective power, compare the energy in kWh that 1kg of the two objects emit over their lifetime (one discharge time in case of the battery). Which object wins thiscompetition?

for part B) not sure what to do hints would be great.. I am not under standing it...
EDIT: or can someone explain the part B because I am not under standing it.!

part C) i can do after part B..

kWh is another way to say Joules, or energy.
Expected lifetime of a car battery at 50% duty cycle... 3 years to be optimist.
Expected lifetime of the sun... let's say 5 billions years.
Convert the two times in hours, then multiply by the respective power emitted per kilogram.

Part B is just that, the asker wants to know how much is the total energy the two systems can give over their entire lifetime.

How did you get the solar W/kg ?
 
solar luminosity/solar mass = W/KgP.S thank you Quinzio.seto
 
Last edited:
hey.. could someone hint me in part C

for part c can i assume that i can use E=mc^2
 
Back
Top