How is that homogenous with respect to units?

  • Thread starter Thread starter amimeera
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Units
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on understanding the concept of homogeneity in the context of the universal gas law equation PV=nRT. Participants clarify that "homogeneous" refers to the uniformity of variables throughout a medium, particularly before reaching thermodynamic equilibrium. The main focus is on verifying that the units on both sides of the equation match, emphasizing the importance of dimensional analysis. Participants explain that pressure (P) and volume (V) yield units of energy, which align with the units derived from nRT, confirming the equation's dimensional correctness. Ultimately, the equation PV=nRT is affirmed to be dimensionally accurate.
amimeera
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
how is that homogenous with respect to units?
i can't get it!
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
I don't understand the question. "Homogenous" means "the same everywhere." This equation represent the "universal gas law" which by its title implies it is "the same everywhere." Somehow, I don't think that this is what the question is after. Can you give us the full question?
 
amimeera said:
how is that homogenous?
i can't get it!

The scalar field describing the gas property (in this case temperature) is homogenous.

Rev Prez
 
My guess is that the word "homogeneous" here means that the variables in the equation (P,V,T) are the same thoughout the medium, and do not vary from point to point as would happen before they reach thermodynamic equilibrium.
 
sorry
homogenous with respect to units!
 
It looks weird.It makes no sense with "homogeneity",even in Euler sense.

Daniel.
 
amimeera said:
sorry
homogenous with respect to units!
So... is the issue how to show that the units match on both sides?

If so: What are the standard units of each quantity?
 
Doc Al said:
So... is the issue how to show that the units match on both sides?
I'm pretty sure it is...

To the OP : Write the dimensions in terms of [M], [L] and [T] for each quantity on both sides and check that the final dimensions are the same.

[P] (pressure) = [force] / [area] = [mass] [acceleration] [L^-2] = ([M] [length] / [time^2]) * [L^-2] = [M] [L^-1] [T^-2]

Do the others similarly (and get the units for R correct)
 
amimeera:

What I'm guessing you meant to ask is: Is the equation PV = nRT dimensionally correct? In other words, do the "units" on both sides of the equation match?

The answer is: Yes.

In SI units we have:

P is in Pascals. 1 Pa = 1 N m^-2 = 1 kg m^-1 s^-2
V is in cubic metres (m^3).

Therefore PV has units kg m^2 s^-2, which is the same as Joules. Another way to say that is that the dimension of PV is the same as energy.

n has no units.
R is the gas constant, with units J K^-1.
Temperature is in Kelvin (K).

nRT therefore has units of Joules, or dimensions of energy.

Since PV and nRT both have dimensions of energy, the equation PV=nRT is dimensionally correct.
 

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
34
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
58
Views
9K
Replies
8
Views
2K
Back
Top