Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the expected jumping ability of sheep when faced with a steep upward slope, specifically in the context of constructing a barrier to keep them off a property. Participants explore the implications of slope on jumping height, the effectiveness of different barrier designs, and the practical considerations of using natural materials.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Debate/contested
- Technical explanation
Main Points Raised
- Some participants suggest that the average jumping height of sheep is around 90cm, with a recommended fence height of 120cm, but question how this would be affected by a 1M steep bank.
- There is uncertainty about the definition of a "1M steep bank" and its implications for the slope's steepness and horizontal distance.
- Some argue that estimating sheep jumping ability on a slope is complicated due to the biomechanics of jumping and animal psychology.
- A participant proposes that digging a ring ditch could effectively increase the height of the barrier while reducing the amount of wood needed.
- Others mention that sheep may not like to enter ditches, which could affect the design of the barrier.
- There are discussions about the potential for sheep to learn from each other, affecting their behavior around barriers.
- Some participants question whether the slope truly matters if the sheep approach the fence from a perpendicular angle.
- A participant mentions that the fence design could be minimal, consisting of tight horizontal wires, to prevent sheep from cresting the slope.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants do not reach a consensus on how much lower a sheep would be expected to jump on a slope, with multiple competing views on the effectiveness of various barrier designs and the factors influencing sheep behavior.
Contextual Notes
There are limitations in the discussion regarding the assumptions made about sheep behavior, the definitions of slope measurements, and the complexity of predicting jumping ability based on various factors.