How to Find Power Dissipation of different ICs

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around methods for calculating power dissipation in various integrated circuits (ICs) such as voltage regulators, op-amps, comparators, and logic gates. Participants explore different formulas and approaches for both static and dynamic power dissipation, seeking clarity on the variables involved and their implications.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • One participant suggests using PDstatic = Vcc*Icc for calculating power dissipation, indicating uncertainty about the definitions of variables.
  • Another participant proposes a formula for voltage regulators: PDstatic = (Vin-Vout)*Io, questioning the need for load current in calculations.
  • For logic gates, some participants mention using (I^2)Rdon and (1/2)*C*V^2, but express confusion about the applicability of these formulas.
  • A participant asks whether output currents for logic gates should be considered, particularly for AND gates, and discusses the potential neglect of Io for op-amps and static logic gates.
  • There is a query regarding the calculation of power dissipation when using both positive and negative power rails, with a suggestion to double the power calculation.
  • Another participant raises concerns about whether low Icc values for certain ICs would result in power dissipation below a threshold of 100mW.
  • Questions arise about how to approach load current when it passes through FETs and resistors, with a reference to using (1/2 C*Vcc^2) for current calculations.
  • Participants express a desire for general equations applicable to various ICs to avoid asking multiple specific questions.
  • One participant questions whether an output current of 15mA for a logic gate is significant enough to consider for power dissipation calculations.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on the best methods for calculating power dissipation, with multiple competing views and formulas presented. There is uncertainty regarding the significance of certain variables and conditions under which they should be included in calculations.

Contextual Notes

Participants note that the calculations may depend on specific circuit configurations, the presence of parasitic capacitances, and the characteristics of the ICs being analyzed. There is also mention of the need to refer to datasheets for accurate Icc calculation techniques.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for engineers and students working with integrated circuits who are seeking to understand power dissipation calculations and the variables involved in different IC types.

KrNx2Oh7
Messages
19
Reaction score
0
I've been looking over how to find power dissipation for voltage regulators, op-amps, comparators, logic gates, and amongst other things.

Ive looked at some resources and I'm not getting what each variable means.
From what I understood so far I've seen

PDstatic = Vcc*Icc where Vcc and Icc are the supply voltage and currents found in the datasheet

Then for voltage regulators since there isn't a source voltage I used
PDstatic= (Vin-Vout)*Io where you subtract input voltage and output voltage and find the load current from the schematic.

Then for logic gates I use
(I^2)Rdon , where Rdon is the gate source resistance found in the datasheet.
(1/2)*C*V^2, where C is the mos capacitnce also found in the datasheet

ARE ANY OF THESE CORRECT?! There are just too many sources and I just don't know a general way of finding the static PD.

I'll ask about dynamic power dissipation after I get this
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
KrNx2Oh7 said:
I've been looking over how to find power dissipation for voltage regulators, op-amps, comparators, logic gates, and amongst other things.

Ive looked at some resources and I'm not getting what each variable means.
From what I understood so far I've seen

PDstatic = Vcc*Icc where Vcc and Icc are the supply voltage and currents found in the datasheet

Then for voltage regulators since there isn't a source voltage I used
PDstatic= (Vin-Vout)*Io where you subtract input voltage and output voltage and find the load current from the schematic.

Then for logic gates I use
(I^2)Rdon , where Rdon is the gate source resistance found in the datasheet.
(1/2)*C*V^2, where C is the mos capacitnce also found in the datasheet

ARE ANY OF THESE CORRECT?! There are just too many sources and I just don't know a general way of finding the static PD.

I'll ask about dynamic power dissipation after I get this

Correct for the linear voltage regulator question. For static gates, just use Idd and Vdd. The output load is usually light for CMOS circuits that are static.
 
So for op amps and logic gates its only Vcc*Icc found in the schematic? I thought I had to consider the output for let's say an and gate. Don't I take load current and multiply by logic high and add to load current * logic low. Did you mean that there is no Io consideration for op amps and logic gates because its negligible?
 
Last edited:
If I have a positive power rail and negative power rail both Vcc do I use
2*(Vcc*Icc) to get the power

Also when the Vout of the voltage regulator is attached to a power supply I have to find the current for every other part of the circuit that is conncected to that power supply correct?
Is taht only for the voltage regulators

and for eveyrthing else I simply use the Vcc*Icc
 
KrNx2Oh7 said:
So for op amps and logic gates its only Vcc*Icc found in the schematic? I thought I had to consider the output for let's say an and gate. Don't I take load current and multiply by logic high and add to load current * logic low. Did you mean that there is no Io consideration for op amps and logic gates because its negligible?

Opamps and static logic gates would be treated differently. For logic gates with static outputs, the output current would generally be small enough that it could be ignored. Gate power consuption would go up significantly when switching currents are factored in.

For opamps, you need to include the output current.

KrNx2Oh7 said:
If I have a positive power rail and negative power rail both Vcc do I use
2*(Vcc*Icc) to get the power

Also when the Vout of the voltage regulator is attached to a power supply I have to find the current for every other part of the circuit that is conncected to that power supply correct?
Is taht only for the voltage regulators

and for eveyrthing else I simply use the Vcc*Icc

For split supplies, yes, you would need to consider the Icc for each rail.
 
ok thank you for the help so far

So I only need to consider ICs that are above 100mW so I am thinking after looking at spec sheets that the AND gates have very low Icc around uA and Vccs are around 3-5 V and since no output currents are considered these would be well below 100mW right

Now sometimes when I am looking for Io it goes through some FETs and resistors
How am I suppose to approach the load current there

I think it has something to do with (1/2 C*Vcc^2) to get current?

edit again:
APA300-PQ208A
For this programmable logic device Do I multiply Vcc*Icc by the number of Vdd inputs there are which seems to be 8 in this case.

And thus if this was connected to the output of a voltage regulator the Io I have to find is it also Icc*8?
 
Last edited:
I feel like I'm asking too specific questions
Is there some general set of equations I can look at to apply?

I have a lot of different types of ICs so I wouldn't want to bother people with a 100 specific questions

last specific question:

It says for the logic gate that the output current low or output current high is around 15mA. Isn't that high enough to consider the output current for power dissipation?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
KrNx2Oh7 said:
ok thank you for the help so far

So I only need to consider ICs that are above 100mW so I am thinking after looking at spec sheets that the AND gates have very low Icc around uA and Vccs are around 3-5 V and since no output currents are considered these would be well below 100mW right

Now sometimes when I am looking for Io it goes through some FETs and resistors
How am I suppose to approach the load current there

I think it has something to do with (1/2 C*Vcc^2) to get current?

edit again:
APA300-PQ208A
For this programmable logic device Do I multiply Vcc*Icc by the number of Vdd inputs there are which seems to be 8 in this case.

And thus if this was connected to the output of a voltage regulator the Io I have to find is it also Icc*8?

KrNx2Oh7 said:
I feel like I'm asking too specific questions
Is there some general set of equations I can look at to apply?

I have a lot of different types of ICs so I wouldn't want to bother people with a 100 specific questions

last specific question:

It says for the logic gate that the output current low or output current high is around 15mA. Isn't that high enough to consider the output current for power dissipation?

Can you give the context of your questions? There are a lot of things that go into calculating currents and powers.

For example, logic circuits generally are switching at some rate. The parasitic capacitances that the logic outputs have to drive generally determine the output currents. Even though the logic outputs are driving high impedance logic inputs, the parasitic capacitance that they are also driving can take up a fair bit of current.

And on PLDs, you will generally need to look at their datasheet for Icc calculation techniques.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
8K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
3K
Replies
10
Views
5K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 52 ·
2
Replies
52
Views
9K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
5K