How to solve for unknown charge position

5 replies · 2K views · last reply
PhizKid
Messages
477
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement


Diagram of two charged particles on a horizontal x axis, particle 1 at the origin and particle 2 a distance L to its right, with a y axis drawn upward through particle 1.

Homework Equations


Coulomb's Law

Coulomb's law force equation: F = k_e q1 q2 r-hat21 / r21 squared, written as typeset vector notation.


The Attempt at a Solution


Here are 2 different possibilities I drew that I think will have the x component vectors and y component vectors cancel out, but I think there may be some other positions as well.

Diagram of a horizontal x axis and vertical y axis with a positive charge labeled 1 at the origin and a negative charge labeled 2 to the right, separated by distance L. A third charge q3 sits below-left, with force arrows drawn from it toward charges 1 and 2 and blue component arrows along the axes.


Diagram of a charge at point 1 on the x-axis labeled 1+ and a charge at point 2 labeled 2- separated by distance L, with a third charge below-left and blue force arrows and black position vectors drawn from it.


##\textbf{F}_x = k_e [\frac{(1.0 \textrm{ uC} \cdot q3) \cdot cos(\theta_1) \cdot \hat{r}_{13}}{{r_1}^2} + \frac{(-3.0 \textrm{ uC} \cdot q3) \cdot cos(\theta_2) \cdot \hat{r}_{23}}{{r_2}^2}]##

##\textbf{F}_y = k_e [\frac{(1.0 \textrm{ uC} \cdot q3) \cdot sin(\theta_1) \cdot \hat{r}_{13}}{{r_1}^2} + \frac{(-3.0 \textrm{ uC} \cdot q3) \cdot sin(\theta_2) \cdot \hat{r}_{23}}{{r_2}^2}]##

But there are so many unknowns and I only have one equation (Coulomb's) so I'm not sure what to do from here.
 
You should be able to narrow the search considerably by considering:

1) If two forces are to completely cancel, what must be their relative directions?
2) What are the directions that the electric forces act between the fixed charges and the unknown charges?

In what way do the answers to the above two items constrain the possible location of q3?
 
Hint: For two vectors to be able to cancel each other, what angle must they make with each other?

That should simplify your answer.

Edit: gneill beat me to it!
 
gneill said:
You should be able to narrow the search considerably by considering:

1) If two forces are to completely cancel, what must be their relative directions?
2) What are the directions that the electric forces act between the fixed charges and the unknown charges?

Oh, as I was thinking about answering your questions I just realized I need to completely review vectors...but now I see that the unknown charge has to be somewhere axis along the fixed charges, but since the force is inversely proportional to the distance, it can't be on the right side because the charge on the right would overpower the one on the left.
 
Okay, so the magnitudes of the two forces have to equal each other:

##k_e \cdot \frac{|q_1||q_3|}{{r_1}^2} = k_e \cdot \frac{|q_2||q_3|}{({r_1 + L)}^2}##

Cancel out the constant and unknown charge:

##\frac{|q_1|}{{r_1}^2} = \frac{|q_2|}{({r_1 + L)}^2}##

But here I have a question about the signs of the force. Since we're only working with the magnitude, do I need to add a negative sign somewhere?
 
I suggest that you make another drawing and use it to further narrow down the region of interest. Then you can write expressions for the force magnitudes without any signs involved. For example:

Number line with a +1.0 μC charge at 0 (red dot) and a -3.0 μC charge at 10 (larger blue dot), with arrows showing force directions in three regions: opposite directions with the further charge dominant, same direction, and opposite directions with the nearer charge dominant.


The diagram shows there's only one region that the third charge can be located so that zero net force can occur.

Since all the given values have similar units (μC, cm), you can drop those too when you write the equality.
 
Attachments
  • Number line with a +1.0 μC charge at 0 (red dot) and a -3.0 μC charge at 10 (larger blue dot), with arrows showing force directions in three regions: opposite directions with the further charge dominant to the left, same direction with no cancellation between, and opposite directions with the nearer charge dominant to the right.
    Fig1.gif
    3.3 KB · Views: 573
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: 1 person