Samson4
- 242
- 15
What happens if a hydrogen molecule is stripped of an electron? Will it become 2H+ or will it become H and H+?
The discussion revolves around the effects of stripping an electron from a hydrogen molecule, specifically whether it results in two H+ ions or one H and one H+ ion. Participants also explore the electric field strength required to remove the final electron from ionized hydrogen and the methods of ionization involved.
Participants do not reach a consensus on whether stripping an electron from a hydrogen molecule results in H2+ or H and H+. There are multiple competing views on the methods and conditions required for ionization, particularly regarding the effectiveness of electric fields versus photon energy.
Participants mention the need for high voltages and specific conditions for ionization, but there are unresolved assumptions regarding the feasibility of these methods and the exact requirements for electric field strength.
Samson4 said:What happens if a hydrogen molecule is stripped of an electron? Will it become 2H+ or will it become H and H+?
You can estimate the needed strength by knowing the second ionization energy. Actually ionization by DC field is almost impossible, either you will want to use electron impact ionization or XUV radiation having enough photon energy.Samson4 said:What electric field strength is needed to remove the final electron from the ionized hydrogen? I am assuming a high enough voltage would strip the last electron an dissociate the hydrogen gas.
The H2+ molecular ion is stable.Samson4 said:What happens if a hydrogen molecule is stripped of an electron? Will it become 2H+ or will it become H and H+?
blue_leaf77 said:You can estimate the needed strength by knowing the second ionization energy. Actually ionization by DC field is almost impossible, either you will want to use electron impact ionization or XUV radiation having enough photon energy.
There is this strong field ionization that does rely on the field more than the photon energy to realize the ionization. Typically this is done by focusing an ultrashort high intensity laser pulse onto the gas target.Samson4 said:You mean ionization by the field alone is almost impossible?
That's where the problem lies. Check out "barrier suppression ionization", and use the formula for the so-called critical field (in V/m) to estimate the needed E field strength. Upon getting the value you will realize that using DC field (such as parallel plates or cathode-anode arrangement) and assuming no collisions with free electrons are possible, , the required voltage is just too unreachable.Samson4 said:of sufficient voltage
blue_leaf77 said:That's where the problem lies. Check out "barrier suppression ionization", and use the formula for the so-called critical field (in V/m) to estimate the needed E field strength. Upon getting the value you will realize that using DC field (such as parallel plates or cathode-anode arrangement) and assuming no collisions with free electrons are possible, , the required voltage is just too unreachable.