I need to calculate the equivalent resistance

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
SaiTatter
Messages
2
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


The circuit is the one in "Fig.4"
Photo of a printed Romanian textbook page showing circuit diagrams: Fig. 3 resistors R1 to R5 between A and B, Fig. 4 a resistor network between A and B with resistors R and points C, D, E, and Fig. 5 a network with R1 to R4 between A, B, C, D, plus exercise text.

I need to calculate equivalent resistance between A and B. This is what I've tried:
Handwritten circuit sketch on graph paper: a resistor R shorted by a wire from A, then a branch of two parallel resistors R with currents I1 and I2 summing to I, followed by a series resistor R to B; below, a redrawn version with a parallel pair feeding a resistor R to B.

I think that the first resistor is shorted by that wire connected between A and E. Their answer looks like this, in fig 2.2.1. I'm not sure if their answer is wrong, or my idea about electricity has flaws. Thanks in advance for the explanations!
Circuit schematic labelled Fig. R 2.2.1 with terminals A=E on the left and B on the right, showing four resistors labelled R, with C=D marked at the junction between the two branches.
 
Attachments
  • Photo of a printed Romanian textbook page showing circuit diagrams: Fig. 3 resistors R1 to R5 between A and B, Fig. 4 a resistor network between A and B with resistors R and points C, D, E, and Fig. 5 a network with R1 to R4 between A, B, C, D, plus exercise text.
    dTMsA0n.jpg
    62.2 KB · Views: 957
  • Handwritten circuit sketch on graph paper: a resistor R shorted by a wire from A, then a branch of two parallel resistors R with currents I1 and I2 summing to I, followed by a series resistor R to B; below, a redrawn version with a parallel pair feeding a resistor R to B.
    w0ZCnUq.jpg
    47.3 KB · Views: 777
  • Circuit schematic labelled Fig. R 2.2.1 with terminals A=E on the left and B on the right, showing four resistors labelled R, with C=D marked at the junction between the two branches.
    jrpmShY.jpg
    74.5 KB · Views: 671
Welcome to the PF. :smile:

Their answer/figure is correct. Just notice how point "A" connects to one side of those 3 R resistors, and the other side of each of those 3 R resistors are all connected together.
 
Thanks berkeman! So proud to be here :).
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: berkeman
[QUOTE="SaiTatter]
I think that the first resistor is shorted by that wire connected between A and E.[/QUOTE]

That's not correct. The wire doesn't connect one side of the resistor to the other side. It connects it to another resistor.

Note that some nodes (eg A and E) are connected together by wire so they are really the same electrical node. Try renaming node E to node A. Likewise for any other nodes that have two names. It might help to colour the wires so points that are connected together are the same colour.

How many different nodes are there? The answer only has 3.

Then redraw the circuit starting with a line of these 3 nodes. Then add the resistors between them.