If bosons don't interact, then how can gravity affect the path of light?

nomadreid
Gold Member
Messages
1,748
Reaction score
243
One says that bosons do not interact with one another. However, the presence of a gravitational field, and hence of gravitons (bosons) (assuming they exist), changes the probability of where a photon (boson) appears, which is the same sort of interaction as two fermions, no?
And, the contrary: mass-energy tells space how to bend, and this bending of space is essentially the gravitational field, so isn't this an interaction of photons and gravitons?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
"One says that bosons do not interact with one another."

Who says?
 
Perhaps what one means is that bosons do not obey the Pauli exclusion principle.

This needs to be compared with fermions: Even non-interacting (i.e. no many-body interactions) fermions repel each other due to the Pauli exclusion principle. Bosons on the other hand do not repel in case of no many-body interactions.
 
Let's not guess what the OP means; let him explain it himself.
 
mass-energy tells space how to bend, and this bending of space is essentially the gravitational field, so isn't this an interaction of photons and gravitons?
I think there should be a feynman diagram for it?
 
I think there should be a feynman diagram for it?
Sure. One choice for the electromagnetic Lagrangian is

L = - ½ Aμ,νAμ,ν = - ½gμσgντAσ,τAμ,ν = - ½(ημσ + hμσ)(ηντ + hμσ)Aσ,τAμ,ν

from which one can pick out the vertex that couples two photon lines and a graviton.
 
Oops, my apologies to all who responded; I misread an article ( "The Computational Complexity of Linear Optics", by Scott Aaronson and Alex Arkhipov), which outlines experiments using non-interacting bosons -- and I misread the way this phrase to mean that all bosons were like that. But after the challenge by Meir Achuz, I re-read it and understood my mistake. My thanks to Meir Achuz (like mea achuz~100%?), Regel, Vanadium 50, adrien, and Bill K.
:blushing:
 
nomadreid said:
My thanks to Meir Achuz (like mea achuz~100%?)
You have outed me. Now you know my test score, and my safah.
 
Back
Top