If we lose our hearing, are afferent nerves still firing?

  • Thread starter Thread starter icakeov
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    hearing loss
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the effects of loud sounds on hearing, specifically whether damage occurs to the ear's mechanics or the afferent nerves responsible for signal transmission. Participants clarify that hearing loss from loud sounds typically results from damage to the middle or inner ear structures, particularly the hair cells, rather than directly affecting the nerves. The conversation touches on the concept of phantom pain to illustrate that neural pathways may remain intact even when sensory input is lost. Additionally, there is a debate about the role of excessive vibrations from loud sounds, with some arguing that these vibrations primarily affect the eardrum's ability to function rather than causing nerve damage. However, it is noted that a significant portion of hearing loss is indeed linked to nerve damage and inner ear hair cell deterioration. The distinction between the eardrum and cochlea is also clarified, emphasizing their separate roles in the hearing process.
icakeov
Messages
379
Reaction score
27
If we lost our hearing from a loud sound, does that just mess up the mechanics of the ear or does it affect the afferent nerves that would actually carry the signal if it could be detected?

Thanks for any responses!
 
Biology news on Phys.org
Well, first, what kind of sound are you talking here?
 
Any sound that an ear can detect. I wasn't talking about vibrations that the skin can detect, but I guess, a similar question could be framed for that one too. :)

Or did you mean more, different sounds can affect different parts of the hearing system? In that case, I would be talking about the sounds that would, for example "destroy" vestibular duct in the inner ear right between between 20Hz and 20KHz in humans.
 
Last edited:
icakeov said:
If we lost our hearing from a loud sound, does that just mess up the mechanics of the ear or does it affect the afferent nerves that would actually carry the signal if it could be detected?

As far as I am aware, hearing loss from loud sounds is usually just the result of damage to the middle/inner ear, not the nerves.
 
  • Like
Likes icakeov
Interesting! Thanks Berk!
 
Yes, thanks for your response berkeman. Basically both can get damaged!
 
FWIW have you heard of phantom pain? People have a leg amputated. Several years later the leg that is not there seems 'itchy' or has some other problem.

The reason is the answer to your question. Just because some neural input is turned off for whatever reason does not mean that the rest of the neural input 'machinery' that originally handled the input automatically switches off or dies . You can present to a physician with tinnitus in a totally deaf ear.

Computer analogy: Just because a peripheral device is disconnected or gone South does not mean the kernel automatically unloads the drivers and powers off the interface cards.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phantom_pain
 
  • Like
Likes icakeov
Sweet! Such a great addition Jim! That really does address the question on so many additional levels. Thanks!
 
  • #10
Loud sound has nothing to do with hearing nerves or amplification process. The only reason is that it creates heavy vibrations on inner cochlear region in which ear drum is present. These excessive vibrations above normal makes ear drum rigid that ultimately reduce the ear drum capacity to vibrate.
 
  • #11
Thanks for your response @Stephen Albert. So you are saying that there hasn't been any research that shows that nerve tissue damaged due to loud sound? It is all a matter of the vibration of the ear drum (or not).
In that sense, if we could replace the ear-drum cells (or in some way, found a way to take away the rigidity), would that mean that we would hear again?
Thanks again
 
  • #12
Stephen Albert said:
Loud sound has nothing to do with hearing nerves or amplification process. The only reason is that it creates heavy vibrations on inner cochlear region in which ear drum is present. These excessive vibrations above normal makes ear drum rigid that ultimately reduce the ear drum capacity to vibrate.

This is not correct. Roughly 90% of hearing loss results from nerve damage or damage to the hairs and hair cells of the inner ear. See here and here, along with the link in post #5.

Also, the eardrum isn't part of the cochlea. It isn't even directly connected to the cochlea, instead being connected to the ossicles (bones in the middle ear) which are themselves connected to the cochlea.
 
  • Like
Likes icakeov and berkeman
  • #13

Similar threads

Back
Top