Impact of frequency on Faraday cages

AI Thread Summary
Faraday cages block electromagnetic fields by redistributing electric charges, resulting in zero electric charge inside. They are effective for high-frequency electromagnetic signals but can be less effective for very low frequencies due to the nature of electromagnetic wave propagation. The discussion highlights that sound waves, which are much lower in frequency than radio waves, can still be heard inside a Faraday cage, as the cage does not block sound. The effectiveness of a Faraday cage depends on its design and the frequency of the signals it aims to shield against. Clarifying the distinction between electromagnetic signals and sound waves is crucial for understanding the limitations of Faraday cages.
stanley
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
I've been reading about faraday cages. The way I see, it works because the condutor will separate the charges so that the eletric charge inside is 0.
Then I saw a lecture in which the professor was carrying a radio and the signal stopped as soon as he entered the cage however we were still able to hear him talking through the speakers, he said that's because the speakers were in a much higher frequency.
My questions are:
  • Why the fact that the eletric charge inside the condutor being 0 blocks electromagnetic fields?
  • Why aren't faraday cages effective for high frequency waves?
  • Why aren't they effective for very low frequencies?
  • Are there better ways to block low frequency waves than with a faraday cage?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
stanley said:
Summary:: Faraday cages and low/high frequencies

I've been reading about faraday cages. The way I see, it works because the condutor will separate the charges so that the eletric charge inside is 0.
Then I saw a lecture in which the professor was carrying a radio and the signal stopped as soon as he entered the cage however we were still able to hear him talking through the speakers, he said that's because the speakers were in a much higher frequency.
My questions are:
  • Why the fact that the eletric charge inside the condutor being 0 blocks electromagnetic fields?
  • Why aren't faraday cages effective for high frequency waves?
  • Why aren't they effective for very low frequencies?
  • Are there better ways to block low frequency waves than with a faraday cage?
Welcome to the PF. :smile:

In one part of your question, you are asking about DC electric fields. In the next part of your post, you are asking about RF radio transmission fields.

Can you post a link to what you have been reading, and say what your end goal is in understanding this? What are you wanting to shield from what?

Thanks.
 
  • Like
Likes stanley
berkeman said:
Welcome to the PF. :smile:

In one part of your question, you are asking about DC electric fields. In the next part of your post, you are asking about RF radio transmission fields.

Can you post a link to what you have been reading, and say what your end goal is in understanding this? What are you wanting to shield from what?

Thanks.
Mostly here and here.

As for what I'm wanting to shield from, I just want to know when and WHY a faraday cage might not be able to completely block EM signals(i.e when the frequency is either too high or too low)
 
stanley said:
Mostly here
The title of that article is nonsense, so I didn't bother reading any farther. Quiz Question for you -- why is that nonsense to try to talk about a Faraday cage shielding magnetic fields? Lordy.
Does a Faraday cage block all magnetic field frequencies lower than x?

stanley said:
and here.
Sorry, I don't usually bother with YouTube videos as scientific references. There are exceptions of course, but on basic stuff that you want to learn about, it's usually okay to start at Wikipedia:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faraday_cage

Also, if you want to learn more about the shielding of RF EM fields, it's good to go to a website of a manufacturer of shielded enclosures:

http://www.ets-lindgren.com/solutions

The main issue for RF shielding is how seamless the metal shield is, especially for feed-throughs that need to go through the enclosure walls (like for power and communication wiring, HVAC, etc.), and for doors for access into the room. There are different ways to do the RF gasketing that is needed for such entry doors...
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes anorlunda
stanley said:
Summary:: Faraday cages and low/high frequencies

Then I saw a lecture in which the professor was carrying a radio and the signal stopped as soon as he entered the cage however we were still able to hear him talking through the speakers, he said that's because the speakers were in a much higher frequency.

This really doesn't make sense as written and need for you to clarify

Did he have speaker(s) inside the cage playing music or something ?
If so, then the cage ISNT going to stop sound waves from coming out

Sound from speakers is MUCH lower than the radio frequency he would have been using
and Faraday Cages ONLY work on radio signals
stanley said:
Why aren't faraday cages effective for high frequency waves?

They are very effective at high, very high and right up to microwave frequencies when designed for the required frequency

eg. the grid shield on your microwave oven door very effectively stops 2.4GHz microwave radio signals from escaping

stanley said:
Why aren't they effective for very low frequencies?

as long as they are radio frequencies, they are effective
stanley said:
Are there better ways to block low frequency waves than with a faraday cage?

Again, Faraday Shields ( cages) are effective as long as it is for radio ( electromagnetic) signalsYou seem to have some misunderstandings around low and high frequencies and if they are electromagnetic or sound.
And that is what is causing your confusionDave
 
I was using the Smith chart to determine the input impedance of a transmission line that has a reflection from the load. One can do this if one knows the characteristic impedance Zo, the degree of mismatch of the load ZL and the length of the transmission line in wavelengths. However, my question is: Consider the input impedance of a wave which appears back at the source after reflection from the load and has traveled for some fraction of a wavelength. The impedance of this wave as it...

Similar threads

Back
Top