Why Should You Study Feynman Path Integrals in Quantum Mechanics?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the significance of the Feynman Path Integral formulation in quantum mechanics, particularly in the context of a course that may have skipped this topic. For undergraduate students, it is generally advised not to prioritize this material yet. However, graduate students interested in High Energy Physics or condensed matter theory are encouraged to explore it, as it can enhance their understanding of path-dependent processes, which are crucial in both physics and engineering. While some participants express skepticism about the necessity of Feynman's ideas, others assert that grasping path integrals and related concepts is essential for a deeper comprehension of quantum mechanics and may even be fundamental for advanced topics like Quantum Gravity. Overall, curiosity and a desire to excel in the field are strong motivators for self-study in this area.
ptabor
Messages
14
Reaction score
0
My QM prof skipped over the topic of the Feynman Path integral formulation...

Is this material important enough that I should learn it on my own (personal curiosity aside)?

The Text is Principles of Quantum Mechanics by R. Shankar
 
Physics news on Phys.org
What is the level of the course? I assume either upper div. undergrad or 1st semester grad.

If you're an undergrad, I wouldn't worry about it yet. If you're a grad student and you're pretty sure you want to do High Energy then it would be worth your time to get starting learning the material.

But most working physicists don't use Feynman path integrals in their research, so it's not so necessary that you run out and learn it now.

Of course, if you're really curious, then it doesn't matter how important it is...just see what you can pick up.
 
HonkyTonk said:
If you're a grad student and you're pretty sure you want to do High Energy ...
or condensed matter theory
...then it would be worth your time to get starting learning the material.
 
Just ask him to teach you.
 
ptabor said:
My QM prof skipped over the topic of the Feynman Path integral formulation...

Is this material important enough that I should learn it on my own (personal curiosity aside)?

if you consider yourself a physics person... you should at least know the ideas behind it
 
no, since feynman was a moron, compared to those of us posting anonymously of PF, his ideas can safely be ignored.
 
mathwonk said:
no, since feynman was a moron, compared to those of us posting anonymously of PF, his ideas can safely be ignored.

I take it this is supposed to be humorous?
 
mathwonk said:
no, since feynman was a moron, compared to those of us posting anonymously of PF, his ideas can safely be ignored.
:smile:

I take it this is supposed to be humorous?
He just being sarcastically contrarian. :biggrin:

Path integrals are important, and more generally, understanding path dependent processes and states is exceedingly important if one wants to be really good in one's field, be it physics or engineering.
 
Path integrals are important, and more generally, understanding path dependent processes and states is exceedingly important if one wants to be really good in one's field, be it physics or engineering.

Very well said, and so those who are either pragmatic or curious would do well to both read up on Feynman path integrals as well as the Calculus of Variations.
 
  • #10
Some might argue that [in spite of current mathematical difficulties] Path Integrals may be more fundamental [for (say) Quantum Gravity] than "standard" approaches to Quantum Mechanics.
 
  • #11
Path integrals is doing quantum mechanics when you are doing classical mechanics. see Feynman and Hibbs
 

Similar threads

Back
Top