Suggestion Include country in forum stats?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Femme_physics
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
Including country information in forum stats could enhance understanding of diverse perspectives, as cultural and educational backgrounds vary significantly. However, concerns about privacy and the potential for increased visual clutter on posts have been raised. Some users suggest that a small flag or optional display could address privacy issues while still providing valuable context. The relevance of nationality is acknowledged, particularly in specific forums like politics and academic guidance, but it is not deemed essential by all members. Overall, the idea is seen as interesting but requires careful consideration of user preferences and privacy.
Femme_physics
Gold Member
Messages
2,548
Reaction score
1
Include "country" in forum stats?

Just seems like a nice thing to be able to view someone's country when you read their posts (not having to go the extra effort and click their profile). It might give us an introspection to an international PoV of people about certain subjects since countries vary so much in culture and education.

Just my 2 cents,
 
Physics news on Phys.org


Femme_physics said:
Just seems like a nice thing to be able to view someone's country when you read their posts (not having to go the extra effort and click their profile). It might give us an introspection to an international PoV of people about certain subjects since countries vary so much in culture and education.

Just my 2 cents,

A worthy request! However something we try to remain aware of is the level of non discussion noise on the page. Member post bits are already fairly large.
 


Also, there can be a privacy issues. I have no problems with people knowing I am from Poland, but I know users that prefer to hide their localization.
 
Last edited:


Greg Bernhardt said:
A worthy request! However something we try to remain aware of is the level of non discussion noise on the page. Member post bits are already fairly large.

Pshaw, all I got is the fact I'm online and my post count. I tell you what, it's all those admins and moderators that hog all the space with their fancy titles rendered in blue-meet-green photoshopped awesomeness and inexplicable Halloween costume avatars that no on should wear... *shakes head in disappointment* Such a shame...
 


Femme_physics said:
Pshaw, all I got is the fact I'm online and my post count. I tell you what, it's all those admins and moderators that hog all the space with their fancy titles rendered in blue-meet-green photoshopped awesomeness and inexplicable Halloween costume avatars that no on should wear... *shakes head in disappointment* Such a shame...

you'd look so amazing in gold :)
 
i don't think the country matters, but the time-zone would be nice …

it would be particularly useful to know when someone is posting at 3am and really should be told to give up and get some sleep! :smile:

oh, and Dory, if you had had an avatar, you wouldn't have had to change your name! :wink:
 


Maybe a little flag next to your name that wouldn't take up much space?
 
cristo said:
Maybe a little flag next to your name that wouldn't take up much space?

trouble with that on other forums is that some people choose a flag because they think it's pretty! :rolleyes:
 


Borek said:
Also, there can be a privacy issues. I have no problems with people knowing I am from Poland, but I know users that prefer to hide their localization.

Regarding this concern, there is no reason to make it mandatory, and very little way to enforce truthfulness in any case.
 
  • #10


I've been a member here for a long time and nationality of another member has never been a concern. What's important is the Science.
 
  • #11


I agree it's not of vital importance, I just think it would be an interesting to know and most forums include it. It may add a bit more introspection, interaction and social understanding between members.

oh, and Dory, if you had had an avatar, you wouldn't have had to change your name!

That's true! :(

you'd look so amazing in gold :)

*grins...bites lower lip...thinks...bolts to the store!*
 
  • #12


dlgoff said:
I've been a member here for a long time and nationality of another member has never been a concern. What's important is the Science.

It is sometimes relevant in the politics forum.
 
  • #13


Femme_physics said:
*grins...bites lower lip...thinks...bolts to the store!*

Think harder o:)
 
  • #14


NeoDevin said:
It is sometimes relevant in the politics forum.

It is often relevant in the Academic Guidance forum.
 
  • #15


NeoDevin said:
It is sometimes relevant in the politics forum.

jtbell said:
It is often relevant in the Academic Guidance forum.

Okay. I wasn't considering those since I hardly go there.
 
  • #16


NeoDevin said:
It is sometimes relevant in the politics forum.

Nothing is relevant in the politics forum. :devil:
 
  • #17


There's a privacy issue. I'm concerned about what would happen if it got out that I am a US citizen.
 
  • #18
Jimmy Snyder said:
There's a privacy issue. I'm concerned about what would happen if it got out that I am a US citizen.
Even worse, what if it got out that I'm a Maineiac?

http://www.101arw.ang.af.mil/shared/media/ggallery/hires/AFG-090209-006.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #19


Jimmy Snyder said:
There's a privacy issue. I'm concerned about what would happen if it got out that I am a US citizen.

You'd find your long lost cousin Irene Roberta Snyder knocking at your door. You'd better turn the lights off quick!
 
  • #20


I support this idea, but there should be a little option that says "hide nationality" or something. That fixes the privacy issue right up, wouldn't you say?
 
  • #21


Users don't have to fill it in :)
 

Similar threads

Replies
18
Views
3K
Replies
21
Views
2K
Replies
26
Views
3K
Replies
33
Views
4K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Back
Top