Infinte distance with finite energy?

  • Thread starter Thread starter maughanster
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Energy Finite
AI Thread Summary
An object can theoretically travel an infinite distance with finite energy if it maintains a positive total energy, as suggested by Newton and Kepler's principles. The discussion explores the relationship between energy, velocity, and distance, highlighting that while the math may imply infinite travel over an infinite time with infinitesimally small energy, practical considerations like acceleration complicate this scenario. It is noted that a body could accelerate to an infinitesimally small speed and continue indefinitely at that speed. The conversation acknowledges the challenges of explaining these concepts clearly, especially for those with limited physics background. Ultimately, the conclusion is that under certain conditions, infinite travel with finite energy is indeed possible.
maughanster
Messages
20
Reaction score
1
Let's say we have an object. And we then say that E = (1/2)mv2.
so we solve for velocity and say that
v = (2E/m)^(1/2)

then integrate both sides with respect to time

∫(2E/m)^(1/2)dt= ∫v dt

so we then have

(2E/m)^(1/2)t = distance

so if time was infinitely large (long) could an object travel an infinite distance if it was given in infinitesimally small unit of energy?

as i typed this out i realized that without an acceleration in obviously could but in my head this math means it's accelerating infinitely slow.

Don't hate me if this is wrong. I've only taken Calc 1 and high school physics. and I also have trouble explaining my scientific thoughts to others haha oh well. Please be indepth when denying my math. I also did substite E for (1/2)mv^2 at

∫(2E/m)^(1/2)dt= ∫v dt

this part but i got d = d^(1/2) for an answer. Thanks!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Newton's first law tells us that this must be true.
 
Hmm, it's a little difficult for me.
 
But could you accelarate the object over an infinite distance with finite energy?
 
Remember that E is a function of time, at least I think it is, so the integral might not be so simple.
 
maughanster said:
But could you accelarate the object over an infinite distance with finite energy?
Not unless it is a hyperbolicalaly decreasing acceleration -- but you can just briefly accelerate to an infinitessimally small speed and just continue at that speed forever.
 
With what you just said and thinking things through a bit I think I finally figured out what i wanted to in the first place. thanks!
 
I agree with Russ Watters, but also would like to light up some extra points.
The situation of traveling forever is possible if the total energy of the body is positive. You can't just express E = 1/2 mv^2.
That would be the case if you are thinking that the body is alone in the space but in real life it is in a number of fields. So, the only condition according to Newton and Kepler is taking the total energy to be positive. So, the answer is YES. A body can travel infinite distance with finite energy.
 
Back
Top