Interference - two waves of different frequencies - beat velocity

4 replies · 3K views · last reply
LmdL
Messages
72
Reaction score
1
Hello,
I'm considering the "beats" phenomena. I have two plane waves in some medium with a refractive index n(ω), one propagates in a z direction and second in a direction making an angle θ with z axis. Waves have frequencies ω1, ω2 (not necessarily equal) and k-vectors k1, k2 (not necessarily equal):

Diagram of two overlapping plane-wave beams: one horizontal beam along the z axis labelled k1, omega1, and a second beam at angle theta to the z axis labelled k2, omega2, with wavefronts drawn as lines.


Now, I'm interested in interference (in the area where both waves overlap) along the z axis direction. I can write the initial fields contributions along the z axis as
Two equations for plane waves: E1 = E0 cos(ω1 t − k1 z) and E2 = E0 cos(ω2 t − k2 cos θ z).

So their sum is
Equation for the superposition of two waves: E+ = E1 + E2 = 2E0 cos((ω1 − ω2)/2 · t − (k1 − k2 cos θ)/2 · z) cos((ω1 + ω2)/2 · t − (k1 + k2 cos θ)/2 · z), with Δω, Δk, ωc and kc labelled beneath the terms.

First cosine is the envelope modulation and second is the carrier wave. Now, my question is regarding the modulation speed. As far as I understand, the above describes the beats phenomena. Or, alternatively, an interference pattern with a period of 2π/Δk that moves in time. If I'm right, the modulation speed reads
Equation for modulation velocity: v_m equals Δω over Δk, which equals (ω1 − ω2) over (k1 − k2 cos θ).

And here is the question: this speed can exceed c (speed of light), once I change the θ. For some θ I can even get an infinite vm (when denominator vanishes). On the other hand, modulation speed should be limited by the speed of light. What I'm missing here?
The possibilities that I thought of:
1. This modulation speed is a sinusoidal and cannot transfer any information, thus isn't limited by c.
2. The expression for vm is correct, but for values of θ that lead to vm>c it should be constrained vm=c .
3. The expression for vm is an expression for phase velocity and I should use d(Δω)/d(Δk) instead (group velocity). However, in this case I also get velocities that exceed c (checked numerically).

Any advice or thoughts are appreciated.
Thank you.
 
The modulation speed need not be limited by c because it is not the speed of a particle or wave. It is the speed of a feature in a pattern, which is an abstract, non-physical concept, and hence not limited by the speed of light.
As another example of how this can happen, consider a powerful, perfect laser mounted perpendicularly on an axle in the middle of a sphere with radius one light second and pointing directly at the sphere's inner surface. The laser rotates on the axle at a rate of one full rotation per 3 seconds, so that the dot of light it makes on the sphere's inner surface traverses a full equatorial circle of the sphere in that time - distance covered = 2 pi light seconds - more than twice the speed of light. Yet the laser itself is only moving quite slowly. This can happen because the only thing moving on the sphere's inner surface is a feature in a pattern - not a physical thing limited by c.
 
Thank you for your reply. I got your point. I have an additional question: let's suppose I place a particle on the z axis (in the waves overlapping area) and restrict it to move along z axis, for example by adding two transparent parallel to z axis plates, one slightly above it and one slightly below. Particle is then confined to one of the modulation wave maxima (similar to optical tweezers). What will happen now? I suppose that if vm is below c, the particle will move with that speed along the z axis, being in the area of the modulation maximum it was confined to from the beginning. What if vm>c? Particle will "slip" to the next maximum to the left, and then again, and again, and so forth? Is this correct?
 
Why would the particle move at all? What force are you expecting to act on the particle to accelerate it out of a stationary state?
 
Never mind. I need to review my understading of optical tweezers. Thank you for your help!