Is a Router Enough Without XP's Firewall?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Metallicbeing
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Router
AI Thread Summary
Windows XP Pro with SP2 includes a firewall that can slow down broadband connections. Users with a router may not need the Windows firewall since routers block unsolicited incoming traffic unless configured otherwise, providing adequate inbound protection against threats like non-email worms. However, local firewalls can still be beneficial for preventing reverse-connect trojans and monitoring outbound traffic, as routers do not provide outbound protection. For users who practice safe browsing habits, relying solely on a router may suffice without a local firewall. There is uncertainty about the outbound protection capabilities of the original XP SP2 firewall.
Metallicbeing
Messages
71
Reaction score
0
I'm running Windows XP Pro w/ SP2. The so called "firewall" has slowed my broadband down considerably. I was told that if I had a router, I didn't need Window XP's "firewall". Is this true?
 
Computer science news on Phys.org
The router will not forward any incoming traffic to you (unless you set it up to do so) of which you didn't initiate the connection. So no non-email worms attempting to exploit windows bugs will do any harm. So for inbound protection there is no need for a local firewall. You may still want to use a firewall on your computer to avoid reverse-connect trojans for example, where the server actually connects to the client. Spyware or other malicious programs could still send data to whoever wants to receive it.

I have a router, and I don't use a firewall on my computer. In practice, if you are a 'safe user' there is not really a need for a firewall when using a router.
I also don't know whether XP SP2's firewall has got outbound protection, at least the original didn't.
 
Thanks El-Half.
 
el-half said:
I have a router, and I don't use a firewall on my computer. In practice, if you are a 'safe user' there is not really a need for a firewall when using a router.
I also don't know whether XP SP2's firewall has got outbound protection, at least the original didn't.

How's AO doing these days? :smile:
 
Last edited:
This week, I saw a documentary done by the French called Les sacrifiés de l'IA, which was presented by a Canadian show Enquête. If you understand French I recommend it. Very eye-opening. I found a similar documentary in English called The Human Cost of AI: Data workers in the Global South. There is also an interview with Milagros Miceli (appearing in both documentaries) on Youtube: I also found a powerpoint presentation by the economist Uma Rani (appearing in the French documentary), AI...
Back
Top