Is Entropy More Than Just a Statistical Measure of Disorder?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lehel
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Entropy
AI Thread Summary
Entropy is a statistical measure of disorder and uncertainty, closely tied to Gibbs Free Energy, which is defined as enthalpy minus temperature times entropy. There is a suggestion that understanding entropy requires knowledge beyond thermodynamics, specifically in statistical mechanics and quantum mechanics. The discussion highlights that while entropy relates to the number of microstates, it does not directly contribute to an increase in unusable energy; rather, energy transformation typically increases overall entropy. Additionally, the relationship between free energy and temperature indicates that higher temperatures correlate with greater disorder in a system. Overall, a deeper understanding of entropy necessitates exploring its complexities beyond basic thermodynamic principles.
lehel
Messages
15
Reaction score
0
Hello,

I've been recently learning thermodynamics and have some questions about entropy. First off, I understand that it is a statistical measure of disorder and uncertainty and understand the 2nd and 3rd laws fairly well.

My question pertains more to Gibb's Free Energy. As I've learned it, there is only a certain amount of usable energy that can be done as non-expansion work that is equal to enthalpy - temperature*entropy. Thus, I am querying if there is something more to entropy than statistic. Does a system that has increased in entropy increased in energy, and some type of energy that is bound to entropy only? Is the disorder increase related to this unusable energy? I guess I'm wondering if entropy is somehow physical rather than just mathematical.
 
Science news on Phys.org
The answer is that entropy is more complicated than that. You're not going to get it from studying thermodynamics. You need to study statistical mechanics to get a better hang of entropy, and you really need some basic understanding of quantum mechanics to understand it properly.

If you are just studying thermodynamics, don't worry too much about what entropy actually is.
 
K^2 said:
The answer is that entropy is more complicated than that. You're not going to get it from studying thermodynamics. You need to study statistical mechanics to get a better hang of entropy, and you really need some basic understanding of quantum mechanics to understand it properly.

If you are just studying thermodynamics, don't worry too much about what entropy actually is.

Well, its more for my own interest of understanding entropy. I was trying to figure out if the the energy that can't be used as work was somehow related to the number of microstates or something like that and if so, how.
 
I think that entropy doesn't contribute to increase in "unusable energy". It's just transformation of energy usually increases overall entropy because energy transformation transmits information.

Free energy associates with temperature, and it's apparent that hotter the system is, more disorder the arrangement is.
 
Thread 'Thermo Hydrodynamic Effect'
Vídeo: The footage was filmed in real time. The rotor takes advantage of the thermal agitation of the water. The agitation is uniform, so the resultant is zero. When the aluminum cylinders containing frozen water are immersed in the water, about 30% of their surface is in contact with the water, and the rest is thermally insulated by styrofoam. This creates an imbalance in the agitation: the cold side of the water "shrinks," so that the hot side pushes the cylinders toward the cold...
Back
Top