I Is equilibrium vapor pressure different in vacuum and in air?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the relationship between the vapor pressure of water and the presence of another gas in the system, challenging the assumption that equilibrium vapor pressure remains constant regardless of other gases. It explores the thermodynamic principles governing the Gibbs energy of the system, indicating that equilibrium occurs when the molar Gibbs energies of the liquid and gas phases are equal. The analysis reveals that the vapor pressure is influenced by the air pressure present, leading to different equilibrium curves at the same temperature but varying air pressures. The derived formula suggests that saturated vapor pressure changes when mixed with another gas, contradicting traditional assumptions. Further exploration of the derivation is suggested to clarify the role of the molar volume of water in the calculations.
GilSE
Messages
8
Reaction score
3
TL;DR Summary
I've made some calculations and found that equilibrium vapor pressure depends on air pressure above the liquid. Is it true?
It’s usually being assumed that points of equilibrium liquid – its vapor is given by a curve in the (P,T) coordinates, and this curve doesn’t change no matter is there another gas in the system or not. For example: if water is put in the empty volume, it will obviously vaporize, filling the emptiness, until vapor pressure reach equilibrium value (at this temperature). If the volume hadn’t been empty but filled with air, the water still would vaporize until the equilibrium and the equilibrium vapor pressure would be the same as in the “vacuum case”. But this assumption looks not obvious for me, I had tried to prove it using thermodynamics, but got an unexpected result.


My reasoning:

The system contains of two phases: the gas one and the liquid one. The liquid one is represented by water with the molar volume v_{w} and the molar Gibbs energy \varphi_{w} . The gas one is represented by water vapor and by air. Pressure which is produced by molecules of air is p_{a} and doesn’t change no matter what happens, partial pressure of water vapor is p_{v} . The molar Gibbs energy of the gas phase is \varphi_{g} , the molar volume of the gas phase is v_{g}. No water molecules can leave the system.


If the pressure and the temperature is the same everywhere in the system, an expression for the total Gibbs energy of the system would be ( \nu in this expression stands for corresponding amount of substance):

\Phi(p, T) = \varphi_{w}(p, T)\nu_{w} + \varphi_{g}(p, T)(\nu_{v} + \nu_{a})

When vaporization or condensation occur, the total Gibbs energy will change because \nu_{w} and \nu_{v} are changing. Amount of air in this processes obviously doesn't change.

So, change of the total Gibbs energy when small change of liquid/vapor amount has occurred:

d\Phi = \varphi_{w}d\nu_{w} + \varphi_{g}d\nu_{v}

Also, if amount of vapor has increased by d\nu, amount of liquid should decrease by d\nu and vice versa:

d\nu_{v} = -d\nu_{w}

Taking this in account:

d\Phi = (\varphi_{w} - \varphi_{g})d\nu_{w}

With such conditions in the system, processes must decrease Gibbs energy. Thus, if \varphi_{w} is not equal to \varphi_{g} phase transitions will occur. Equilibrium is possible only if \varphi_{w} = \varphi_{g} .


Everywhere at the equilibrium curve \varphi_{w} must be equal to \varphi_{g}, hence, when moving along the curve, Gibbs energy of gas phase and Gibbs energy of liquid phase must change identically: d\varphi_{w} = d\varphi_{g} , what could be rewritten as:

-s_{w}dT+v_{w}d(p_{v}+p_{w}) = -s_{g}dT+v_{g}d(p_{v}+p_{a})

Air pressure doesn’t change:

-s_{w}dT+v_{w}dp_{v} = -s_{g}dT+v_{g}dp_{v}

Let’s transform the expression above with the notice that change of an entropy during an isothermal process is equal to the received heat divided by the temperature, \Delta s = s_{g}-s_{w} = \frac q T , where q is the heat consumed to transform 1 mol of liquid water to vapor.

(s_{g}-s_{w})dT = (v_{g}-v_{w})dp_{v}

\frac {dp_{v}} {dT} = \frac q {T(v_{g}-v_{w})}


Now, let’s write down the ideal gas law for 1 mol of the gas phase and express v_{g} from it.

p_{v}+p_{a} = \frac {RT} {v_{g}}

v_{g} = \frac {RT} {p_{v}+p_{a}}

Then, substitute it into the previous equation, also assuming that v_{w} \ll v_{g} .

\frac {dp_{v}} {dT} = \frac q {Tv_{g}}

\frac {dp_{v}} {dT} = \frac {q(p_{v}+p_{a})} {RT^2}


Solve this differential equation:

\frac {dp_{v}} {p_{v}+p_{a}} = \frac {qdT} {T^2}

\ln(p_{v}+p_{a}) + \ln\left(\frac 1 C\right) = -\frac q T

p_{v}+p_{a} = Ce^{-q/T}


Let’s it’s known that when T = T_0 and p_{v} = p_{v_0} the system is in an equilibrium state.

p_{v_0}+p_{a} = Ce^{-q/T_0}

C = (p_{v_0}+p_{a})e^{q/T_0}

p_{v}+p_{a} = (p_{v_0}+p_{a})e^{q(1/T_0-1/T)}

p_{v} = (p_{v_0}+p_{a})e^{q(1/T_0-1/T)}-p_{a}

p_{v} in this expression – vapor pressure in an equilibrium state. We can see that this pressure depends on air pressure, so at the same temperature but at the different air pressure equilibrium curves will differ.

P.S. I hope TeX language in this post will render correctly. I did my best to format it like in other posts on the forum but for some reason it still doesn't render in preview.
 
Last edited:
Science news on Phys.org
Bystander said:
Thank you! So, saturated vapor pressure is different when another gas is mixed with it. Though, the formula I got isn't the same as in Wikipedia (at least, the Wikipedia formula includes v_w factor which was omitted in my derivation). Should I resolve the equation without omitting it? But it seems that in this case I'll get Ei() function in the solution, so I don't think that it improve the situation.
 
I need to calculate the amount of water condensed from a DX cooling coil per hour given the size of the expansion coil (the total condensing surface area), the incoming air temperature, the amount of air flow from the fan, the BTU capacity of the compressor and the incoming air humidity. There are lots of condenser calculators around but they all need the air flow and incoming and outgoing humidity and then give a total volume of condensed water but I need more than that. The size of the...
Thread 'Why work is PdV and not (P+dP)dV in an isothermal process?'
Let's say we have a cylinder of volume V1 with a frictionless movable piston and some gas trapped inside with pressure P1 and temperature T1. On top of the piston lay some small pebbles that add weight and essentially create the pressure P1. Also the system is inside a reservoir of water that keeps its temperature constant at T1. The system is in equilibrium at V1, P1, T1. Now let's say i put another very small pebble on top of the piston (0,00001kg) and after some seconds the system...
Back
Top