Is Free Will Just an Illusion? A Look at Benjamin Libet's Research

  • Thread starter Thread starter BigMacnFries
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Brain
AI Thread Summary
Benjamin Libet's research on free will raises significant questions about the nature of human behavior and consciousness. While his findings suggest that brain activity precedes conscious decision-making, leading some to challenge the concept of free will, it is important to note that Libet himself does not conclude that all behavior is solely brain-based. He introduces the idea of a "free won't," where individuals can veto actions indicated by readiness potentials. This suggests that not all actions are predetermined by brain processes. The discussion emphasizes that while certain biological responses may be automatic, they do not encompass the entirety of conscious experience. The autonomic nervous system's role in survival is highlighted as an example of how physical reactions can occur without conscious intent, indicating a more complex interplay between brain activity and conscious decision-making.
BigMacnFries
Has anyone Benjamin Libet's work on free will (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benjamin_Libet is a brief summary). Does anyone know of any objections to why his work does not suggest that all behavior is brain based. Does it seem really weird to anyone one else that all this I/ you are doing could be physically based?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
We had a couple of threads on Libet's work a few months ago. It does indeed throw a challenge to the concept of free will.
 
As usual, everyone is overlookign the fact that Libet himself does not draw
an anti-free-will conclusions. Readiness potentials are not always followed
by actions, which Libet considers as constituing a veto or "free won't".
 
I don't see a basis for the leap from Libet's study to the conclusion that human behavior is only brain-based. So what if part of the biological system is programmed or reactive, that doesn't mean all of consciousness is. To me it is logical that the physical system could react without conscious direction to help with survival (isn't the autonomic system doing some of that?). So if my hand wants to move before I will it to, that might just be my autoreact system beating out my will system.
 
Thanks, i found the previous thread, very interesting
 
Every day we learn new things. Sometimes it's just a small fact or realization. No matter how trivial or random, let's start recording our daily lessons. Please start off with "Today I learned". Keep commentary to a minimum and just LIKE posts. I'll start! Today I learned that you clean up a white hat by spraying some cleaner with bleach on it (rinse before putting it back on your head!)
Back
Top