Discussion Overview
The discussion explores the hypothetical transformation of electrical thunderstorms into electromagnetic pulse (EMP) storms through energy enhancement. Participants examine the feasibility of this concept, comparing it to nuclear EMP events and discussing the nature of thunderstorms and lightning.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Debate/contested
- Conceptual clarification
Main Points Raised
- Some participants question the feasibility of transforming thunderstorms into EMP storms, noting that standard thunderstorms lack the necessary power and energy compared to nuclear EMPs.
- One participant suggests that if thunderstorms could be enhanced to the level of nuclear detonations, it might be possible to create an EMP effect.
- Concerns are raised about the practicality of such energy enhancement, with one participant likening it to a magical process.
- Another participant references the Carrington event as a more significant concern than the proposed transformation of thunderstorms.
- Some argue that even if all lightning energy on Earth were combined, it would not equate to the energy of a nuclear bomb, suggesting that enhancing lightning energy is implausible.
- One participant describes a rare atmospheric event where multiple lightning strikes occurred simultaneously, suggesting a natural occurrence of a large-scale EMP-like effect, though it was not confirmed to cause equipment failure.
- Disagreement exists regarding the role of cosmic rays in the atmosphere and their impact on lightning formation.
- Participants discuss historical nuclear tests and their global electromagnetic effects, questioning the relevance of thunderstorms in this context.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants generally do not agree on the possibility of transforming thunderstorms into EMP storms. Multiple competing views remain regarding the feasibility and mechanisms of energy enhancement, as well as the implications of lightning and cosmic rays.
Contextual Notes
Some participants express skepticism about the energy levels involved in lightning compared to nuclear devices, while others highlight the rarity of atmospheric events that could produce significant electromagnetic effects. The discussion includes references to historical events and theoretical concepts without reaching a consensus.