Is it safe to be exposed to SHF or EHF for a very long time?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Miss Amy
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Time
AI Thread Summary
Long-term exposure to SHF or EHF frequencies, typically associated with microwave radiation, is generally considered safe at low intensities, according to the scientific community. Concerns about health risks, such as cancer, have not shown significant increases despite the rise in usage of devices like cell phones and Wi-Fi. The heating effect is the primary concern, requiring substantial power to cause harm, rather than ionizing radiation, which SHF and EHF do not fall under. These frequencies can penetrate some flesh and bone, and their use in civilian areas is expected to increase, particularly with advancements like 60 GHz RF technology. Overall, the consensus indicates minimal risk from low-intensity exposure to these frequency bands.
Miss Amy
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
Is it safe to be exposed to SHF or EHF for a very long time? Like, hypothetically, there was an ear device in my ear that operated in the SHF or EHF frequency band. Would it be safe for me to use it for a long time especially since they're microwave bands(?). Are microwave bands bad for you? I read that they're within 30MHz to 300GHz, which includes VHF and UHF as well. It shouldn't be too bad, could it?

Also, between the two bands, how often is SHF and EHF used in a civilian area (including suburban, city, and airport)?

Can they also pass through some flesh and bone without disappearing completely?

Thanks in advance.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
Miss Amy said:
Like, hypothetically, there was an ear device in my ear that operated in the SHF or EHF frequency band.
Why would you have an RF transmitter in your ear?
 
berkeman said:
Why would you have an RF transmitter in your ear?
Ha Ha. You couldn't hear yourself think!
I thought all the hoo haah about personal radio sources was put to bed some while ago. A 100mW transmitter couldn't work continuously for long in a hand held device. One hour's exposure to the heating effect would give just 0.367kJ. Putting a wooden pad over your cheek would cause a bigger temperature rise than from the phone.
I suspect that much of the 'injury' that people complain about is due to physics rubbing against the skin.
 
I thought the issue with radiation was more to do with the frequency that the little photons wiggle with when they hit something, if they are wiggling fast enough then they tend to knock the wee electrons off of their mommy atoms and then bad things happen? I don't think you want too many of those nasty photons. Basically once you go above the higher end of the UV spectrum is where those problems start, microwave off course doesn't even make it into the visible spectrum.

Or, you get hit with lots and lots of lower wiggle rate photons, that can also cause problems, but those are problems that generally come with being "cooked" regardless of the heat source, and you need a lot of power for that because water takes many joules to change temperature.
 
berkeman said:
Why would you have an RF transmitter in your ear?
https://www.bestbuy.com/site/plantronics-m95-bluetooth-headset-black/5709005.p?skuId=5709005&ref=212&loc=1&extStoreId=448&gclsrc=aw.ds&ds_rl=1255843&ds_rl=1260579&ds_rl=1266837&ref=212&loc=1&gclid=Cj0KCQiAwc7jBRD8ARIsAKSUBHKRqjVvUOm1QMfRA6Y-j8HVMl5dnV0SFOEhnZ1X0hWJ1Nwp_vQbbH8aAkDVEALw_wcB

...or is that an "in" vs "on" objection?
 
  • Like
Likes berkeman
essenmein said:
frequency that the little photons wiggle with when
photons don't wriggle
 
davenn said:
photons don't wriggle
I mean how can they, they have no time.
 
Miss Amy said:
Is it safe to be exposed to SHF or EHF for a very long time?
depends on the power level and your definition of "a long time"
and since you have told us nothing about this RF source, its pretty difficult for anyone to give you a decent answer
 
Last edited:
essenmein said:
I mean how can they, they have no time.
Sorry, but that response, as with your previous post doesn't make much sense
 
  • #10
davenn said:
Sorry, but that response, as with your previous post doesn't make much sense

Photons travel at the speed of light, therefore experience zero time over their journey, however long or far it is from our perspective.

Then the issue with electromagnetic radiation causing problems in humans is generally due to the secondary ionizing aspect, which only happens at a sufficiently high energy level, or wavelength, or frequency (wiggle rate), you don't need many of these high energy photons to start causing problems, or its direct heating where you need a lot of power (lots of photons).
 
  • Like
Likes russ_watters
  • #11
essenmein said:
Photons travel at the speed of light, therefore experience zero time over their journey, however long or far it is from our perspective.

that's basically true, but don't forget, photons are not little bullets zipping along at high speed, they are quantum packets of energy

But it is not relevant to the topic of the thread :wink:

essenmein said:
Then the issue with electromagnetic radiation causing problems in humans is generally due to the secondary ionizing aspect, which only happens at a sufficiently high energy level, or wavelength,

this is true but again, not relevant to the topic that stated SHF to EHF :smile:
essenmein said:
(wiggle rate),

PLEASE stop using that termDave
 
  • #12
davenn said:
this is true but again, not relevant to the topic that stated SHF to EHF :smile:

I thought the question was re human harm due to long term exposure to SHF or EHF, my point was meant to be, neither are short enough wavelength (or enough energy, I shan't mention their wiggle) to fall into the ionizing radiation category, therefore my understanding is that any harm can only come from direct heating, which requires power.
 
  • Like
Likes davenn and russ_watters
  • #13
essenmein said:
therefore my understanding is that any harm can only come from direct heating, which requires power.

correct, which is why I stated that to the OP in a previous post :smile:
 
  • #14
Miss Amy said:
Is it safe to be exposed to SHF or EHF for a very long time? Like, hypothetically, there was an ear device in my ear that operated in the SHF or EHF frequency band. Would it be safe for me to use it for a long time especially since they're microwave bands(?). Are microwave bands bad for you? I read that they're within 30MHz to 300GHz, which includes VHF and UHF as well. It shouldn't be too bad, could it?

The consensus of the professional scientific and medical communities is that low intensity radio/microwave radiation poses no known danger to human health. As far as I'm aware, the rates of cancer and other diseases that could be linked to non-ionizing radiation have not increased significantly even though the use of transmitters (cells phones, wifi, cell towers, etc) has increased a thousand-fold or more in the last few decades.

That's about as close to a "no, there's no danger" as you can get in medicine.

Miss Amy said:
Can they also pass through some flesh and bone without disappearing completely?

Yes they can.
 
  • Like
Likes davenn, anorlunda, Miss Amy and 1 other person

Similar threads

Back
Top