Is Life Possible in a Deterministic Universe?

  • Thread starter Thread starter hypnagogue
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the implications of the 'parallel universes' interpretation of quantum mechanics, suggesting that each wave function collapse leads to the creation of multiple universes, each reflecting different outcomes of quantum measurements. This perspective posits that while quantum behavior appears random, it may actually follow deterministic mathematical laws in certain universes, potentially misleading scientists into believing classical determinism applies at the atomic level. The conversation explores the idea that if the fundamental nature of reality is inherently random and indeterministic, we might just inhabit a universe where these random events have coincidentally aligned with established physical laws. The notion raises questions about the implications for life, with a humorous acknowledgment that if quantum particles behaved deterministically, it could lead to a paradox where life, as we know it, might not exist, thus questioning the feasibility of such a scenario.
hypnagogue
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
Messages
2,283
Reaction score
3
Let's assume the 'parallel universes' interpretation of quantum mechanics is accurate, and that each time a wave function is collapsed, the universe "branches off" into multiple incarnations of itself to accommodate each possible outcome of the quantum measurement.

It therefore follows that there will exist at least several such universes in which the behavior of quantum particles, although randomly generated, will appear to follow a set of well-defined mathematical laws. Scientists will have been duped into thinking that classical determinism extends all the way down to the atomic level!

Now imagine by analogy that the fundamental natural order of ALL nature is in fact random and indeterministic in the flavor of the quantum mechanics we know, regardless of scale. We just happen to exist in one of those rare parallel universes where every random 'quantum' event occurring on a sufficiently large scale, up till now, has followed well-defined mathematical laws, i.e. the laws of physics. But like the scientists of the last paragraph, we're in for a big surprise sooner or later... Better hope you don't wake up tomorrow with a fork for a nose.

...twilight zone?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Unlikely. :wink:
 
Ahh, but if atoms obeyed the laws of classic physics, no life would be possible. So it seems that this trick wouldn't work, since there would be no humans to be deceieved.
 
I obviously was being facetious with this post... but just wondering anyway, since I haven't heard this idea before-- why would life be impossible if quantum particles acted deterministically?
 
Every day we learn new things. Sometimes it's just a small fact or realization. No matter how trivial or random, let's start recording our daily lessons. Please start off with "Today I learned". Keep commentary to a minimum and just LIKE posts. I'll start! Today I learned that you clean up a white hat by spraying some cleaner with bleach on it (rinse before putting it back on your head!)

Similar threads

Back
Top