Is My Attempt at Solving the Binomial Expansion Homework Correct?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving a binomial expansion homework problem, specifically finding the coefficient of the term in x that equals zero. An initial attempt at the solution yielded the correct answer but contained flawed working, particularly with an incorrect interpretation of -1/0. Participants clarified that the coefficient of x should be isolated, leading to the equation 2a/3 + 2 = 0. The correct value for 'a' was determined to be -3, emphasizing the importance of avoiding undefined expressions in calculations. The conversation highlights the necessity of careful algebraic manipulation in solving binomial expansion problems.
Physics news on Phys.org
bllnsr said:
here's my attempt to part (i)
http://i47.tinypic.com/2yv6y3s.png
is it correct?
You got the correct answer somehow, but your working is flawed. Can you see where?
 
oay said:
You got the correct answer somehow, but your working is flawed. Can you see where?

Ooops. Yeah, I agree. I somehow just read through the bad part. -1/0 should have been a tip off.
 
oh yes -1/0 is -∞ but I made it zero:frown:
a/3 +1 = -1/2x
putting x = 0
a/3 +1 = -1/2(0)
a/3 +1 = -1/0
-1/0 is -∞
a/3 +1 = -∞
if a = -3 is the correct answer how to get this value :confused:
 
Last edited:
The question states "the coefficient of the term in x is zero".

What do you think this coefficient is?
 
somebody told me this general formula
T_{r+1} = \binom{n}{r}a^n b^r
will be used to find 'a' and the statement "the coefficient of the term in x is zero" means
that \binom{n}{r} is 0 and what I did previously is wrong.
I have math exam tomorrow and this is the only question that I cannot solve
 
Last edited:
bllnsr said:
somebody told me this general formula
T_{r+1} = \binom{n}{r}a^n b^r
will be used to find 'a' and the statement "the coefficient of the term in x is zero" means
that \binom{n}{r} is 0 and what I did previously is wrong.
I have math exam tomorrow and this is the only question that I cannot solve

What you did before is almost right. When you get to 1+(2ax/3)+2x=1+(2a/3+2)x the part you want to make 0 is just the coefficient of x, (2a/3+2). Ignore the 1, it doesn't have anything to do with x.
 
@Dick
can you please show me last two steps of how to solve it for a
 
  • #10
bllnsr said:
@Dick
can you please show me last two steps of how to solve it for a

Ok, just for you. 2a/3+2=0, 2a/3=(-2) (subtract 2 from both sides), 2a=(-2)*3 (multiply both sides by 3), a=(-2)*3/2=(-3) (divide both sides by 2).
 
  • #11
Thanks
 
  • #12
bllnsr said:
Thanks

You're welcome. Notice no 1/0 appears. If it does that's a pretty sure sign something is wrong.
 
Back
Top