Is my understanding of Einstein right?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jamin2112
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Einstein
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the perception of Einstein's contributions to physics, particularly in relation to Quantum Mechanics. A PBS documentary criticized Einstein for failing to unify Relativity and Quantum Mechanics, suggesting he might have changed his views had he lived longer. However, participants argue that Einstein's critics often lack a deep understanding of his work and the historical context of his debates with other physicists. They emphasize that despite his criticisms, Einstein made significant contributions to Quantum Mechanics and had a strong track record of adapting his theories based on new evidence. The conversation concludes that many criticisms of Einstein are unfounded, as he remains a pivotal figure in the field.
Jamin2112
Messages
973
Reaction score
12
My background is Mathematics. I'm thinking about learning Physics as a hobby. I know a little Physics from courses and research I did in college. I rented from the public library a few weeks ago a PBS documentary on Einstein because I wanted to have a basic idea of his life and theories. The video was very critical of Einstein. It said that shortly before Einstein died, Quantum Mechanics had become a popular theory and Einstein had desperately tried to unify the field of Relativity and Quantum Mechanics but had failed to do so. They said that if Einstein was alive today to see Quantum Mechanics, he might've changed his mind about many things.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Such documentary are often scripted by illiterate people who have no knowledge and even less understanding of the debates Einstein had on these questions with prominent physicists of that time. Remember also that Einstein won the Nobel price for its contribution to quantum mechanics.

Have a read at this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bohr–Einstein_debates

and then switch to the hard side for which you are well prepared.
 
Or read a good biography of Einstein: "Subtle Is the Lord: The Science and the Life of Albert Einstein" by Abraham Pais.
 
Einstein critics

No one has had more critics than Einstein. People are still trying to prove him wrong on various points. The thing about critics is they criticize.
With a degree in math, you are well prepared to learn physics. Ordinary and partial differential equations, vector analysis, some sadistics(sic), form the basics, then tensors for general relativity.
Bits and pieces of other stuff are usually worked into the physics courses, same for tensors.
 
Einstein had a huge impact on quantum mechanics. Do yourself a favor and stop taking those videos seriously.
 
Jamin2112 said:
They said that if Einstein were alive today to see Quantum Mechanics, he might've changed his mind about many things.
Einstein's track record for reconsidering when presented with new data/results that challenged his thinking was very good. So it's quite likely that if he had lived to see some of these new developments, he would have had incorporated them into his thinking, and we'd all have been the richer for it.

If there is one development that I really wish Einstein had lived to see (and he only missed by a few years) it would be Bell's theorem.

he video was very critical of Einstein. It said that ... Einstein had desperately tried to unify the field of Relativity and Quantum Mechanics but had failed to do so.
And so far no one else has succeeded either, so I don't find that criticism especially compelling. It never ceases to amaze me that Einstein is so often criticized for not achieving more by people who have achieved far less.
 
Thread 'Is there a white hole inside every black hole?'
This is what I am thinking. How much feasible is it? There is a white hole inside every black hole The white hole spits mass/energy out continuously The mass/energy that is spit out of a white hole drops back into it eventually. This is because of extreme space time curvature around the white hole Ironically this extreme space time curvature of the space around a white hole is caused by the huge mass/energy packed in the white hole Because of continuously spitting mass/energy which keeps...

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
17
Views
5K
Replies
9
Views
4K
Replies
1
Views
173
Replies
43
Views
9K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
185
Views
6K
Back
Top