Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the search for a low-cost programmable DC ammeter with serial port connectivity, suitable for projects requiring current-flow data logging. Participants explore various approaches, including commercial options and DIY solutions, while considering technical specifications and limitations.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
- Mathematical reasoning
Main Points Raised
- Jason O initiates the discussion by seeking a low-cost programmable DC ammeter with serial port capabilities for data logging, expressing concerns about high-end equipment costs.
- Some participants suggest that existing data loggers may be too expensive, leading Jason to consider building his own device.
- Jason proposes using a shunt with an op-amp and an A/D converter to create a simple ammeter, asking for recommendations on specialized ICs.
- One participant argues that building a device may not be cheaper than purchasing a commercial data logger and highlights the challenges of direct PC data transmission without a microcontroller.
- Another participant mentions that PIC processors have built-in A/D converters and serial ports, suggesting they could simplify the design process.
- Jason expresses interest in using a sound card for data acquisition, questioning the voltage resolution of sound cards and considering the feasibility of sampling the mic input.
- Warren provides information on sound card specifications, noting typical voltage levels and resolution.
- Jason explores an alternative method involving a voltage to frequency converter (LM231) to modulate the output for sound card input, discussing potential implementation strategies for current range adjustments.
- Another participant mentions the availability of inexpensive digital multimeters (DMMs) with serial interfaces, suggesting a potential commercial solution.
- Warren suggests modifying a low-cost sound card to measure DC voltages by shorting its input coupling capacitor, cautioning about voltage limits.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants do not reach a consensus on the best approach, with multiple competing views on whether to build a device or purchase an existing solution. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the optimal method for achieving the desired functionality.
Contextual Notes
Participants express uncertainty about the feasibility and cost-effectiveness of DIY solutions versus commercial products. There are also unresolved technical details regarding the implementation of the proposed designs, such as the effectiveness of using sound cards and the specifications of various components.