Is there an analytical solution to the following problem?

20 replies · 4K views · last reply
deepakphysics
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Differential equation
\begin{align}
\frac{{\partial}^2 T (x,t)}{\partial x^2} = \frac{1}{\alpha}\frac{\partial T(x,t)}{\partial t},
\end{align}

boundary conditions
\begin{equation}
\begin{aligned}
T(x, 0) = T_\infty \\
-k\frac{\partial T(0,t)}{\partial x}= h(T_{max} - T(0,t)) \\
-k\frac{\partial T(l,t)}{\partial x}= h(T(l,t) - T_\infty).
\end{aligned}
\end{equation}

It is 1D transient heat diffusion problem. x[0,L] represents a 1D spatial domain and t[0,tao] represents a time domain. T(x,t) is temperature distribution over the spatial and temporal domain. \alpha = k/(cp*rho), where k is thermal conductivity, cp heat capacity and \rho thermal conductivity.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
T_max is a constant value. T_infinity is also a constant value.
 
Last edited:
Yes doing that we will arrive at solution T(x,t) = (A*cos(w*x)+Bsin(w*x))*T_inf*e^(-alpha*w^2*t).
I have problem now finding values of A, B and W with given boundary conditions.
 
I have got the following Laplace transform
$$\hat T(x,p)=\frac{T_\infty}{p}+C_1e^{x\sqrt{p/\alpha}}+C_2e^{-x\sqrt{p/\alpha}}$$
then we have two equations:
$$k\hat T_x(0,p)=\frac{hT_\max}{p}-h\hat T(0,p),\quad k\hat T_x(l,p)=h\hat T(l,p)-\frac{h T_\infty}{p}$$ and two unknown functions ##C_j=C_j(p),\quad j=1,2## I do not see what is the problem
 
Last edited:
Thank you for the solution. It is possible to find C1 and C2. I got as follows (picture attached) a = alpha Tm = T_max, Ti = T_inf. I am stuck again..how can we find inverse laplace ?
 
Attachments
  • Mathematica output giving two expressions, c1 and c2, each a fraction with a numerator involving a, h, k, p, e, Ti and Tm, and a denominator containing square roots of p/a and powers of e.
    Screen Shot 2016-05-21 at 19.25.51.png
    33 KB · Views: 626
There is a much easier way of solving this problem analytically. The first step is to solve for the steady state solution. What do you get for the steady state solution?

Chet
 
Hi
I have following analytical solution (Please find it in the attachment). T1 and T2 are temperature at the surface of inner and outer wall.
 
Attachments
  • Typeset page of equations 14 to 19 for steady heat diffusion through a concrete ceiling, ending with the solved expressions for T1 and T2 in terms of Tmax and T-infinity.
    Screen Shot 2016-06-05 at 00.17.44.png
    35.4 KB · Views: 714
  • Schematic of a 1D discretised domain: a grey slab of length l with nodes labelled T1,j, T2,j, Ti,j and TN,j, left boundary Tmax, right boundary T∞, heat transfer coefficient α, and index j = 1,2,...,t.
    Screen Shot 2016-06-05 at 00.16.59.png
    9 KB · Views: 687
deepakphysics said:
Hi
I have following analytical solution (Please find it in the attachment). T1 and T2 are temperature at the surface of inner and outer wall.
OK. Let ##T(x,\infty)## represent this final steady state solution. Now express the temperature at an arbitrary time t as follows:
$$T(x,t)=T(x,\infty)-\theta (x,t)$$
Now, if you substitute this into the differential equation, boundary conditions and initial conditions, what do you get (in terms of ##\theta##)?
 
This is what I got. One more thing, T_infty is not the temperature corresponding to steady state solution. It is a ambient temperature. For some reason it should be taken as a variable. The results need to be expressed in terms of T_infty and T_max and other material parameters (h, l, k ).
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten derivation of a heat conduction problem: solution T(x,t) with a steady-state term, the differential equation, initial condition, and two spatial boundary conditions involving K, h, beta and l.
    Screen Shot 2016-06-05 at 11.39.38.png
    54.6 KB · Views: 688
deepakphysics said:
This is what I got. One more thing, T_infty is not the temperature corresponding to steady state solution. It is a ambient temperature. For some reason it should be taken as a variable. The results need to be expressed in terms of T_infty and T_max and other material parameters (h, l, k ).
I understand all this. Now please answer my question in the previous post.
 
Thank you. I have tried to answer your question. I have attached a screen shot in the previous reply (forgot to mention about the attached screen shot).
 
deepakphysics said:
Thank you. I have tried to answer your question. I have attached a screen shot in the previous reply (forgot to mention about the attached screen shot).
Oh, sorry. I missed that.

There is a mistake in your equation for ##T(x,\infty)##. The x should be an x/l. Please make this correction in your initial condition and boundary conditions, and also reduce these equations to a common denominator.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: deepakphysics
Thank you for the correction. Please find the updated results in the attachments.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten derivation of an analytical solution T(x,t) = [K T∞ − 2K Θ(x,t) + K Tmax − hl Θ(x,t) + hl T∞ − hx T∞ + hx Tmax] / (2K + hl), followed by the temporal boundary condition Θ(x,0) and two spatial boundary conditions Θ(0,t) and Θ(l,t).
    Screen Shot 2016-06-05 at 17.09.46.png
    65.2 KB · Views: 706
deepakphysics said:
Thank you for the correction. Please find the updated results in the attachments.
My solution for ##T(x,/infty)## does not match yours. Based on the boundary condition equations you gave in your first post, I get:
$$T(x,\infty)=\frac{-T_{max}+\beta (T_{max}+T_{\infty})+(T_{max}-T_{\infty})x/l}{(2\beta -1)}$$
Note the minus sign in the denominator. Try this and see if it satisfies you boundary conditions.

I suggest that, when you do the formulation in terms of ##\theta##, you continue to use ##\beta## in the equations.
 
I think I did little mistake in the first post. There should have been a minus sign in the left hand side of both equations representing spatial boundary conditions. Also I did mistake in my previous reply. I think I have corrected those mistake this time. Please find the outcome in the attachments I) in terms of \beta and ii) interms of (k,h and l).
 
Attachments
  • Worked symbolic solution in plain text: T(x,t) solution formula, its x-derivative, a factorized form, initial condition solve for g(x,0), and two spatial boundary condition solves for g(0,t) and g(L,t) with beta and k, h, L symbols.
    transientsteady.PNG
    45.6 KB · Views: 568
  • Symbolic math worksheet deriving a steady-state temperature solution T(x,t) with beta = k/(h·m), its x-derivative, the factored form, the initial condition at t=0, and two spatial boundary conditions solved for g(x,t).
    transientsteadynobeta.PNG
    47.2 KB · Views: 631
Chestermiller said:
There is a much easier way of solving this problem analytically. The first step is to solve for the steady state solution. What do you get for the steady state solution?

Chet
We can prove mathematically that the steady state solution exists? That is if ##T(x,t)## is a function that satisfies (1) then the limit ##\lim_{t \to \infty}T(x,t)=f(x)## exists and it is finite?

OR we assume that it exists because we have to do with a physical process that will reach in some sort of equilibrium and that nothing can become infinite in a physical process?
 
deepakphysics said:
I think I did little mistake in the first post. There should have been a minus sign in the left hand side of both equations representing spatial boundary conditions.
Yes. I missed this. I'm editing your original post to correct this.
Also I did mistake in my previous reply. I think I have corrected those mistake this time. Please find the outcome in the attachments I) in terms of \beta and ii) interms of (k,h and l).
I'll check it out in a little while.
 
Delta² said:
We can prove mathematically that the steady state solution exists? That is if ##T(x,t)## is a function that satisfies (1) then the limit ##\lim_{t \to \infty}T(x,t)=f(x)## exists and it is finite?

OR we assume that it exists because we have to do with a physical process that will reach in some sort of equilibrium and that nothing can become infinite in a physical process?
I'm not a mathematician so I couldn't answer whether it can be proven mathematically that there is a stable steady state solution. I let the physics of the situation tell me this, based on an abundance of heat transfer experience. This problem obviously involves convective heat transfer at the two ends of the rod, with the external temperatures being Tmax and T∞.
 
deepakphysics said:
I think I did little mistake in the first post. There should have been a minus sign in the left hand side of both equations representing spatial boundary conditions. Also I did mistake in my previous reply. I think I have corrected those mistake this time. Please find the outcome in the attachments I) in terms of \beta and ii) interms of (k,h and l).
I couldn't read what you had, but here's what I got (for the corrected boundary conditions):
$$T(x,\infty)=\frac{T_{max}+\beta (T_{max}+T_{\infty})-(T_{max}-T_{\infty})x/l}{(1+2\beta)}$$

Initial condition: $$\theta (x,0)=\frac{(T_{max}-T_{\infty})(\beta + x/l)}{(1+2\beta)}$$

Boundary condition at x = 0:$$\frac{\partial \theta}{\partial (x/l)}=\frac{\theta}{\beta}$$

Boundary condition at (x/l) = 1:$$\frac{\partial \theta}{\partial (x/l)}=-\frac{\theta}{\beta}$$