Is there such a site where you can participate projects of all sort?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Alex_Sanders
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Projects Sort
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the search for platforms or websites where individuals can collaborate on various engineering and technical projects, including electronics, programming, and design. Participants express interest in gaining experience, learning from others, and working together on projects, while also sharing resources and ideas.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants suggest websites like discovercircuits.com, hackaday.com, and Make Magazine's online projects site as potential resources for project collaboration.
  • Others express a desire for a platform that facilitates collaboration similar to open-source software projects, where engineers can contribute to larger engineering projects.
  • A participant shares a vision for a social network/service website that allows users to submit project ideas and recruit members to form project teams, highlighting the challenges of ownership and control over contributions.
  • Some participants mention the barriers to collaboration in engineering compared to software projects, noting the need for physical resources and prototyping.
  • There are expressions of personal interest in specific projects, such as building improved vacuum sensors or an Evans Volksplane, indicating a desire for hands-on collaboration.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on a specific platform for collaboration, and multiple competing views about the feasibility and structure of such collaborative projects remain. The discussion reflects a mix of shared interests and individual aspirations without a clear resolution.

Contextual Notes

Participants express various limitations regarding the availability of resources, the nature of project collaboration in engineering versus software, and the complexities of managing contributions and ownership in collaborative projects.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals interested in engineering, electronics, programming, and collaborative project work may find this discussion relevant, particularly those looking for platforms to engage with others in technical projects.

Alex_Sanders
Messages
73
Reaction score
0
You know, like drawing PCB, coding some C, come up with best chip models? And at the same time, gain experience and learn from others?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
check out discovercircuits dot com, forums
 
jim hardy said:
check out discovercircuits dot com, forums


A very content-rich site, thanks!
 
hackaday.com, sparkfun.com, servocity.com, and makazine.coom are places that will get you set up on parts and ideas. Nuts and Volts magazine is also a good place.

I've yet to find a way to work together on projects, which is a bit saddening as I have the deep experience base of an old guy, but lack some of the resources, ingenuity, and determination that I had when younger. It would be fun to have about four guys working together. Especially if the projects were for the shear joy of doing them :-)
 
You might like Make Magazine's online projects site. Wide range of hobbies for the industrious nerd.

http://makeprojects.com/
 
Hello, Jim.

No, I still design electronics, but it's for a consulting firm and most of the work is slapping simplistic building blocks together.

I once worked in semiconductor instrumentation and designed custom instruments for laboratories. Most of this work reaches some point where it's no longer fun, but it was challenging. And, there was a great deal of pride in the results.

Now, I long to develop a process for building improved vacuum sensors and the same for flow sensors. I'd also like to develop an IC to interface vacuum sensors.

Short of that, it might be fun to build a nerf launcher that tracks it's victim via IR bolometers (available at Ti) :-)
 
Is there any project site that has collaboration? Kind of like the open source software projects where people can contribute to larger projects. I would be interested in engineering projects like that. That's what I thought the OP was getting at. I guess there are a lot more barriers to doing a general engineering project this way compared to just a software project.

I remember a site that had freelance projects though. Basically people and companies put out small projects for engineers and technicians to apply for in exchange for payment. This probably wouldn't be the best site to collaborate and learn from others though.
 
DragonPetter said:
I remember a site that had freelance projects though. Basically people and companies put out small projects for engineers and technicians to apply for in exchange for payment. This probably wouldn't be the best site to collaborate and learn from others though.
elance does this.
 
  • #10
I'm game.

I have the layout, simulation, and PLD programming tools as well as lab equipment and over half a life in the R&D business.

If we could get three mentors, EE, CSE, and ME along with three corresponding up and comings, I think we'd probably have a pretty good team.
 
  • #11
Yea I totally want to game, although I'm not in the states, don't know if that's a huge issue...

I can get you guys materials needed though, things are heck lot cheaper here than in the states...
 
  • #12
Actually I had been thinking of creating a social network/service website that allowed people to submit project ideas, and to recruit members of the site to volunteer portions of the project to form project teams.

Say there's an engineer who wants to make a specific design. Maybe he doesn't have access to a machine shop or some software package. He could submit a goal, and the kinds of help and resources the project needs. Then other engineers/techs could browse through all of the submissions and enter themselves into the projects they found interesting. Designs could come together, and if there was a physical/expensive aspect to the design, then at the end of a design people could decide to come together to build it. This is not ideal in an engineering sense since prototyping is very important and you can't really expect to do an entire design before building something, but I don't know how any single member could have ownership and control over other people's contributions. If members joined a project, but had no experience on how to design some things, the creator or other expert members could teach others how to design stuff to get the project going.

You could also have projects that are hobby level where people just help towards an "open source" design. People would choose how much money and resources they would want to contribute, and so the projects would be limited by funding this way. If someone dropped out, the team could simply recruit another person in the pool of members, and so a project would float to the top based on its popularity and progress. The website could accumulate a database of designs, tools, simulators, theories, etc. that are made available to all the members. The website would also include features for communication, project management, etc. Say when you create a project, a forum group is created for that project and an upload space is created along with voting systems and any other interactive tools you'd want to use to organize the team.

If the design was to be a commercial product, the contributors would then own part of the design based on the completion of their tasks. There would also be confidentiality and other legal issues with this route, so I doubt I'd want to tackle that. Perhaps anyone could take the design and make a commercial product with it, so the person with the idea sacrifices their sole right to it so that it can become a reality.

Basically I want a website where companies and open source projects can spontaneously come into existence and cool projects can be collaborated on by people in their part-time that have a genuine interest in them other than making profits. It would bring old and new engineers together on an equal setting, where there is no boss or authority, and where experience/knowledge is admired and respected. There would also need to be some way for physical parts to come into reality. It would be similar to how artists can join an art studio and pool their resources together to create their art.

I know that's a half-baked pipedream, but I think a lot of good things would come from something like that.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads

Replies
20
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • · Replies 37 ·
2
Replies
37
Views
5K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
1K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K