Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

News Katrina commision

  1. Sep 5, 2005 #1
    "katrina commision"

    Hillary clinton seems to think that there should be a federal investigation into how the relief effort got screwed up in the wake of the hurricane. I think that that would be a waste of money, and would get nothing done that couldn't be done in a quicker, easier manor. we all know what went wrong, FEMA wasn't ready for a hurricane like this, and new orleans' leeves wern't built well enough for a cat 4 or 5.

    I do think that the FEMA director should be cabinet level person, its a big job, and one that millions of people rely on being done right.

    What are your opinions?

    http://www.nydailynews.com/news/wn_report/story/343489p-293306c.html [Broken]
    Last edited by a moderator: May 2, 2017
  2. jcsd
  3. Sep 5, 2005 #2
    Investigation is a waste, when has any investigation of any US failure had any positive results? I can't think of a single one. Nothing will come of this, unfortunately.
  4. Sep 5, 2005 #3


    User Avatar
    Gold Member

    And this is the woman who demanded the federal investigation into the Hot Coffee mod in the newest Grand Theft Auto game....
  5. Sep 5, 2005 #4
    Yeah what's with her an her investigations.... They're all just a waste of time anyways.
  6. Sep 5, 2005 #5


    User Avatar
    Gold Member

    It can't be a way to get "her name in the spotlight". Shes the former first lady! I don't think a video game commission is going to be the centerpiece of her 08' campaign.
  7. Sep 5, 2005 #6
    Why is finding the root cause of the problem a waste of money? You cannot fix a problem until you know the root cause. Slapping a bandaid on a severed arm to stop the bleeding will not reattach the arm and fixing superficial problems for disaster management will not improve the ability to handle a disaster. Why were we so late at responding? I don't know. You don't know. An investigation is needed to determine this and when congress or the president screw up the investigating body is usually a commission---a board of people who look at why something failed or to investigate something.
    Last edited by a moderator: May 2, 2017
  8. Sep 5, 2005 #7
    I think the video game thing was a lousy attempt to appeal to those fundamental christians fussing over nudity.

    Let the hijacking begin!
  9. Sep 5, 2005 #8


    User Avatar
    Gold Member

    Comissions of this nature are normally done at the local level I thought (or state). How is this handled in other cases?
  10. Sep 5, 2005 #9


    User Avatar
    Gold Member

    Ha, hilary clinton appealing to christians. Yah right. And pigs can fly.
    Smurf sucks
  11. Sep 5, 2005 #10
    Considering that this was largely a federal failure, it deserves a federal investigation.
  12. Sep 5, 2005 #11


    User Avatar
    Gold Member

    .... state governments are suppose to be at the front line when disasters occur. California has a forest fire, california firefighters respond, not FEMA.
  13. Sep 5, 2005 #12
    It makes me wonder what they are prepared for.

    If they cannot respond to a hurricane they can see coming days in advance, what is going to happen with a catastrophe that strikes suddenly?

    So did Bill Clinton

    The investigation is necessary, you need to find out what went wrong if you intend to fix the problem. If it turns into a witch hunt then it will be a waste of time.

    As I posted in another thread, Bush had all the authority he needed to respond to this catastrophe. He should assume responsibility so that we can move forward. The Department of Homeland Security is a hugely expensive failure.

    There is already finger pointing at who was responsible and the debate is degenerating into how to place and deflect blame. The president should accept responsibility so that the debate can move forward constructively.
  14. Sep 5, 2005 #13
    its a waste of money to do that, and nothing will be accomplished. All one has to do is put the FEMA director on the cabinet, and find a new FEMA director! Of course, new orleans (and alot of LA and mississippi) need fixed, and better evacuation plans need to be made, especially for the poor. there are some minor details that need to be worked out, but the mayor-governor-fema director can do that without a multi-million dollar investigation.

  15. Sep 5, 2005 #14
    Investigations are the key to efficient QA(quality assurance) programs. Anyone who served in the Navy has been to an incident inquary. These inquaries are designed to determine the root cause of failure be it procedural, communications, implementation, etc. These incident inquaries are how the Navy ensures its QA(and Nuc and SubSafe) procedures are followed to prevent the loss of life or equipment.

    Inquaries in and of themselves are not evil. You need to find the root cause of failure(not necessarily finger pointing either) before you can address a problem effectively.
    Last edited: Sep 5, 2005
  16. Sep 5, 2005 #15
    Wow, you seem so certain. I gather you've followed these things for years and years and years. We all know adding cabinet level positions automatically fix things don't we. Heck, we made a Homeland Security position(the result of the 911 commission inquary so I guess they do accomplish some things) and suddenly all of our problems are gone... Wait no we still have problems mobilizing disaster support.
  17. Sep 5, 2005 #16
    If a federal state of emergency is declared, the burden of the response shifts to the federal government. Guess what? One was declared two days before the hurricane hit.
  18. Sep 5, 2005 #17
    Forest fires are not an emergency or a disaster that envolves large numbers of people. The U.S Forest service responds to forest fires anywhere in the country.
  19. Sep 5, 2005 #18


    User Avatar
    Gold Member

    Two days before the hurricane hit? I thought it was 2 days after... hmm ill go look that up.


    Ok well im finding contradictory information so I need your source.
    Last edited: Sep 5, 2005
  20. Sep 5, 2005 #19
    Well then you need to read the news before commenting. There are multiple threads on the site covering the timeline of when a Federal Disaster was declared, when the hurricane made landfall, and the follow on events.

    The disaster was declared before Katrina made landfall in order to free monies and resources in anticipation of a disaster.

    [edit] http://news.google.com/news?q=federal disaster declared&num=100&hl=en&lr=&safe=off&sa=N&tab=wn
    Last edited: Sep 5, 2005
  21. Sep 5, 2005 #20
    The 911 commission had some sucess, but a cloud of secrecy in the guise of national security kept them from finding out what they needed to know.

    There will be no cloud of secrecy on this one, only lies.

    Blanco did something to tick off Bush. Perhaps it was her trip to Iraq and their meeting afterward.
Know someone interested in this topic? Share this thread via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook