Leaky Tank Differential Eqn Problem

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
LongApple
Messages
68
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/electric...s-fall-2011/assignments/MIT6_003F11_sol01.pdf

http://i.imgur.com/8qj5cWE.png

#6 Part B
Page 12 of a 6.003 homework solutions PDF showing Part b with a boxed answer of 0.2 m^3/s and a highlighted explanation that tank 1 overflows when r1 = k1 x 1 m, so r0 < 0.2 m^3/s.


Homework Equations


None[/B]

The Attempt at a Solution


Don't understand why we care about when r1=r0

The tank will overflow when the height of the tank is greater than 1. Why care about r1=r0? What is our motivation for think about the r1=r0 case? That's steady state sure. But they are asking about overflow which I thought just depends on water level

Page 12 of a 6.003 homework solutions PDF showing Part b with a boxed answer of 0.2 m^3/s and a highlighted explanation that tank 1 overflows when r1 = k1 x 1 m, so r0 < 0.2 m^3/s.
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of two water tanks in cascade: water flows in at rate r0(t) into tank 1 with height h1(t), out to tank 2 at rate r1(t) with height h2(t), then out at rate r2(t).
    upload_2015-6-8_4-36-20.png
    22.9 KB · Views: 721
Once r1=r0 the water level in the top tank will cease to rise farther. If that tank has not overflowed by the stage r1 attains r0, then that tank is never going to overflow.

Each tank has two outlets: the normal outlet at its base, and the overflow being its top rim.
 
LongApple said:
Don't understand why we care about when r1=r0

The tank will overflow when the height of the tank is greater than 1. Why care about r1=r0? What is our motivation for think about the r1=r0 case? That's steady state sure. But they are asking about overflow which I thought just depends on water level

View attachment 84595
Max. outflow rate of tank 1 without spilling is r1(h1max). This obviously must be >= r0.
If r0 > r1(h1max) then tank 1 will spill since more water has to flow out of tank 1 than its hole can accommodate.

NOTE: "r1(h1max)" means "r1 of h1max, not r1 times h1max.