Length contraction from two inertial frames

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
7 replies · 3K views
bernhard.rothenstein
Messages
988
Reaction score
1
R' is an observer from I'. A rod is in a state of rest relative to him. He measures its proper length L(0). An observer R from I measures its Lorentz contracted length L related by
L=L(0)sqrt(1-vv/cc) (1). If we reverse the situation, R measuring the proper length of the rod R' measuring its Lorentz contracted length. Please tell me what is the name of the property that makes that (1) holds in that case as well.
Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
bernhard.rothenstein said:
R' is an observer from I'. A rod is in a state of rest relative to him. He measures its proper length L(0). An observer R from I measures its Lorentz contracted length L related by
L=L(0)sqrt(1-vv/cc) (1). If we reverse the situation, R measuring the proper length of the rod R' measuring its Lorentz contracted length. Please tell me what is the name of the property that makes that (1) holds in that case as well.
Thanks


By "reverse the situation" do you mean that the rod is now moving with speed v relative to R instead of R'?
 
bernhard.rothenstein said:
Please tell me what is the name of the property that makes that (1) holds in that case as well.
Thanks

It's the same property, of course. Relativity works both ways. But the problem is how to define the same proper length when when the rod is measured in the two reference frames. When the rod goes from being at rest in one frame to being at rest in the other, how do we know it has the same length? Relativity gives a way to define this.

For an interesting related question, see the forum topic titled "special relativity puzzle," which deals with the problem of hopping from one frame to another.
 
length contraction

HallsofIvy said:
By "reverse the situation" do you mean that the rod is now moving with speed v relative to R instead of R'?

Thanks. Yes. Has the situation something om common with "reciprocity"?
 
bernhard.rothenstein said:
Thanks. Yes. Has the situation something om common with "reciprocity"?

Sorry Bernhard, we weren't answering your question. If you are looking for a general term then, yes, reciprocity describes this type of relationship. Another example of such a relationship is the Golden Rule.:smile: